Impatto delle trasformazioni economiche su sindacati e contrattazione collettiva: crisi, decentramento e nuove forme di partecipazione.
1. The impact of change on labor unions and collective agreements
The changes of the economic context and the diversification of work require a reappraisal not only of employment policies but also of collective bargaining and industrial relations. How to do it is a controversial issue which has received different solutions also by those, governments and social parties, who consider collective bargaining and industrial relations an important instrument of social participation and of employees protection and not an obstacle to the functioning of the economy.
Collective agreement, have been shaped, like statutory law, according to the dominant patterns of standard employment and mostly based on the experience of industrialized countries. If they are to remain a major source of regulation of employment, they too must revise their objectives and practices so as to respond to the diversification of employment patterns, and on the other hand to the globalization of markets.
Indeed these transformations are affecting the system of Industrial Relations even more directly than the legal status of the contract of employment, in so far as industrial relations are exposed, often without any protection, to the pressures of the markets, and because the diversification of work affects the very basis of collective action of the workers, more than the initiatives of the employers.
These factors have altered the power relations among the social parties to the detriment of the labor unions and account for the growing difficulties of traditional Industrial Relations which are visible even in the strongest systems of central and Northern Europe.
However here too the responses of the various national relations are far from uniform as it is shown by the main indicators, in particular by the variation of union density.
Moreover the decline of average union density and the even more pronounced decline of industrial conflict, which has been confined to the public sector, are not fully reflected in the coverage and in the structure of collective bargaining. Here the variations among countries are different from those of Union density due to the impact of other factors, in particular of legislation and of public policies concerning industrial relations.
The coverage of national collective agreements has continued to be relatively high also in countries where the rate of unionization has been traditionally low such as France and Spain and has further declined in recent years. This is due mainly to State legislations which have supported the application of national or multi employer collective agreements beyond the area of unions influence by way of various mechanism of legal extension of these agreements to all the firms and employees of the various economic sectors.
This promotional legislation has not been changed, and indeed has been reinforced in some countries like Germany: while in the past the extension could be decided on the condition in order that the agreement covered the majority of the interested firms and employees, recent legislation has lifted this condition in order to facilitate the extension. It has provided that the extension can be ordered at request of the bargaining parties following a discretionary evaluation of the public authorities.
Moreover minimum wages have been introduced in Germany, one of the few countries of Europe, together with Italy, where they did not exist as a way to sustain the salaries of occasional and precarious types of work, so called mini jobs, which are much lower than the average.
Even in the countries like Italy where a legal system of extension does not exist, other forms of indirect support of the effects of the agreements are in place. Courts decisions and administrative provisions require the respect of the standards fixed by national agreements as a condition to receive various fiscal benefits. The same wage standards are relevant to determine the basis for social security contributions. The role and effectiveness of collective agreements have been indirectly sustained also by the law which recognize the right to bargain only to representative unions, in order to oppose the fragmentation and hence the weakening of the bargaining parties.
These legal interventetions have been important in supporting collective agreements; even though it is doubtful that they may be sufficient to redress the balance of power which is now unfavourable for the unions.
Another form of promotional legislation has been adopted by some countries, and endorsed by an EU directive which grants consultation and participation rights to workers representatives on major enterprise decisions affecting working conditions. The experience of countries where this participation is widely adopted has shown positive results not only in facilitating employment relations, but also in improving both the welfare of workers and the productivity of firms.
This approach however requires a major change of attitude in the culture and practice of the social parties, particularly of the unions most dedicated to conflict and alien to participation. An institutional support to participative Industrial Relations comes also in those countries where unions and employers associations have developed, with legal endorsement, a net of bilateral committees and organizations which administer a considerable number of welfare and training instruments. These bilateral institutions have resisted to the economic crisis and often to the changes of government.
11. Decentralization of collective bargaining structure
The transformation of work and of the markets have exerted strong pressure to decentralize the structure of collective bargaining which in quite a few European countries was rather centralized, as reflected in the central position of national sectorial agreements.
Decentralized bargaining, mainly to the company and plant level, has acquired a decisive role in most countries even where the national and multi employer agreements were traditionally prevalent (se research group n. 4 of the ISLSSL).
The national legislators have encouraged this process of decentralization on various conditions and with a different impact on the role of national agreements. Some legislations (Spain) have completely altered the traditional hierarchy of the bargaining structure by attributing to company agreements the primary role in regulating most labor issues, including the possibility to fix conditions of work less favorable to employees than those set nationally.
A more nuanced solution has been adopted in France where the law has attributed to decentralized agreements priority in the regulation of some issues not reserved to national agreements; but it has provided the duty of the employers to bargain periodically over most labor matters.
Similar measures have been decided, although less clearly, by Italian law, which has recognized to decentralized agreements, contrary to tradition, the same legal status and effectiveness as the national agreements. Moreover collective bargaining has been promoted in specific areas, because some fiscal incentives have been reserved to productivity bonuses and to welfare benefits bargained with the unions, and not to those unilaterally decided by management.
In countries like Germany and Italy the central labor unions have been able to control the process of decentralization, at least in the strong economic sectors and in medium large firms; and have used the possibility to derogate from the national standards mainly in cases of serious economic crisis in order to prevent mass dismissals and plant closures.
In sum these trends indicate a marked alteration of the structure of continental collective bargaining. The national agreements are becoming similar to framework contracts setting basic standards and guidelines more than regulating the actual conditions of work. Wages tend to be linked, above the minima, to the performance of workers and to indicators of business productivity and results.
Decentralized agreements tend to become firm-specific, i.e. dedicated to solve problems of work organization and to administer the daily life of the workplace, mostly through specialized procedures and bilateral committees. In many advanced companies participatory bargaining is competing with innovative HR management for the allegiance of the new and old types of employees.
For the reasons already explained public support to collective activities is important even more than in the past. But the future of the industrial relations depends in the first place on the capacity of the labor movement to find new reasons and objectives for a common action.
The growth and influence of the European unions have been built, differently from the trend prevailing in the USA, not only on collective bargaining, but on a vast spectrum of social and political actions, including the participation within the enterprises and in public institutions in charge of labor policies, training and welfare policies.
The value of this multiplicity of arenas in face of the present global transformations, has been confirmed by most European unions, even though their relations with the traditional labor parties has been loosened, and the declining fortunes of labor friendly governments have often reduced their financial and institutional support to unions activities.
The decline of membership and the increasingly difficult relationship with the State have persuaded many European unions to experiment innovative forms of recruiting activities similar to those practiced by American unions, in particular towards the new types of employees, skilled and unskilled, which populate the present labor markets.
But these practices of union-revitalization have met with uneven degree of success, due the difficulty to overcome the obstacles which contrast collective action and organization.
Forms of collaboration and alliance with other types of social movements have been searched by some unions; but in most cases have remained at an initial stage, due to the difficulty to find common objectives with the traditional goals and often to the resistance of the unions leadership.
In fact greater attention has been given by the unions of the major countries to service activities of different kinds (social assistance, training services) which have proved useful not only to increase the allegiance of members and the attractiveness of membership, but also to compensate for the reduced amount of member dues and of public resources.
The decentralization process of Industrial Relations has been promoted by employers associations; but they have not pushed to abolish national and multi employer bargaining, in this respect converging with the position of the unions. Workers organizations are committed to safeguard the social function of national agreements as guarantee of equality in the basic conditions of work for the employees of the same economic sectors. The employers associations have accepted to maintain this level of bargaining even though reduced in content and made more flexible, in order to respond to the different needs of the firms, because national agreements have proved to be useful to regulate employment contracts of the multitude of small firms, often marginal, which represent the majority in many sectors of the economy. Centralized bargaining has been useful also to exempt these firms from the direct impact of unions and social pressure. At the same time national agreements leave room to the more productive enterprises to regulate differently their employees according to their specific needs.
Compila il seguente form. Ti risponderemo il prima possibile!