In this paper, Professor Tiziano Treu argues that the world of work is changing rapidly and that labor regulations need to adapt to these changes.
Refraiming our field of study
Our field of study and its object, labor and employment relations, have always been changing. Even the name of our association has been changed in 2007, not a common event in the area of social sciences. The history of the association and this very anniversary provide vast evidence of theses changes. In the past, like today, the impact of social and economic transformations has questioned our assumptions and forced us to adapt many aspects of our theories and policy proposals.
What is specific of our times is the speed of change and the depth of the challenges which the great transformations of the world scenario present not only to labor regulations but to the existing social and economic systems.
The challenges are so fundamental that quite a few experts of our field, not to speak of managers and politicians, envisage the decline of labor regulations. A recent analysis based on quantitative analysis of Industrial Relations change has argued that the trajectories of most (advanced) countries indicate a clear trend toward a universal neoliberal transformation of individual relations and in general of the capitalistic systems, which would contradict the traditional interpretative model of the varieties of capitalism.
In this perspective, which is indeed quite controversial, the decline of traditional industrial relations based on collective agreements as a major source of labor regulations might be substituted by Human Resource management and other forms of individual relations. A similar possibility would have a direct impact also on the study of labor relations. A declining legal and collective regulations, challenged by market force and substituted by managerial decisions, would cause a parallel reduction or irrelevance of our discipline.
However it is a fact that the forms of work and of employment relations built in the past century are threatened by the structural factors which altering most aspects of the economy and of the social life, namely globalization and technological innovations. Both factors are not new, but their influence has been growing in the last years at an unprecedented pace.
Even so there is evidence, and I will mention some, that the impact of these factors is not predetermined, but is influenced by the existing institutions and by the political decisions adopted in different times and in the various countries.
Here is the space for the initiative of the actors, public and private, which operate in the various spheres of the social, economic and political life.
There is also a great opportunity for our studies. With their tradition of critical thinking and of experience of interdisciplinary research they may face the difficult challenges of the world of work more appropriately than other disciplines charaterized by less critical and more prescriptive approach to the analysis and management of employment relations.
The challenges to our discipline are so fundamental that no minor adaptation of the traditional policies is sufficient to restore the role of labor law and of industrial relations as effective instruments of social justice and of economic progress. A plus of common efforts is needed for understanding the underlying factors of these challenges.
ILERA and in parallel the International Society for labor and Social Security Law (ISLSSL) have the intellectual and professional resources to support comprehensive research in most controversial areas of labor regulations and labor policies. We have the responsibility to promote research programs based on objective and accurate analysis so to avoid ideological controversies and simplistic solutions. Both indeed are common in our field which is so exposed to social tensions and influenced by diverging interests.
We need also to stress the importance of a comparative approach. Even though the object of our discipline has been built for a century on a national basis, now it is facing an increased interdependence nor only among enterprises and financial institutions, but also between the entire legal and social systems of the various countries.
Comparative analysis -which is different for simple description of the various national systems - is not easy for scholars and for policy makers who have been concentrated for decades on domestic issues, trusting on the specificity of their own solutions. Here too our associations and this meeting provide good examples of innovative comparative research in many areas of labor and industrial relations.
The complexity of these issues and the richness of the experience accumulated in the years does not allow for easy solutions and shortcuts. Broad analysis of the general economic and social trends may be insufficient or misleading. More detailed in depth analysis are necessary to understand the multifaceted reality of employment and of labor regulations and to detect the reactions of the various social and legal systems to the present challenges. Even minute solutions may be important for the daily life of people. Specific micro analysis are important in a period of rapid and uncertain transitions where partial innovations in some areas may be relevant to indicate future evolutions of each system.
European experiences: a testing ground
Given the limit of this presentation and of my knowledge I will concentrate on some traits of labor regulations adopted in Europe, both by the Union and by member States. These European regulations may be a significant testing ground for detecting the reactions of labor law and industrial relations to the transformations of the world of work. The analisys of these reactions may also offer some arguments to test the opinions mentioned above which envisage an inevitable decline of Industrial Relations.
The various European States have different historical traditions and maintain quite a few differences also in labor regulations; particularly so if we consider the eastern countries to which the European Union has been recently enlarged.
But being members of the European Union has intensified the relations among the various countries and the exchange of practices also in labor matters. Moreover the Union as such has contributed to spread common practices and rules in the field of employment and industrial relations, which have built a common social dimension, usually named “social model”.
Relative to most other areas of the world this 'model' is characterized by high standards in the major aspects of labor regulations: guarantees of collective and individual social rights: statutory legal and collective regulations of working conditions; social security and welfare institutions which protect workers from the risks of work and respond to the essential needs of life; extensive practices of collective bargaining and of workers participation.
The European charter of fundamental rights has solemnly confirmed the commitment of the Community and of its member states to observe and implement the basic social standards which are internationally recognized and which are a necessary component of the “decent work”.
The European model represents a quite unique approach to supranational labor regulations, legally more stringent than other forms, bilateral treaties and the like. This peculiar approach allows for multilevel regulatory interventions, national and European, on most labor problems.
In spite of these achievements the established system of social rights and policies has not fully protected the European workers and citizens from the damages of the recent economic crisis. And it does not exempt our countries from facing the new risks and challenges of the future. Indeed these challenges are quite similar to those common to the rest of the world, which threaten the stability of traditional labor regulations and policies.
In recent years the most dramatic challenge has come from the economic crisis which has hit Europe like and even more seriously than other countries, and that has seriously deteriorated the social and economic conditions of its citizens.
The measures implemented by the European States in order to react to this crisis have affected all major public policies in the field of labor and social matters.
The results of these measures have been uneven and quite variable in the different member States. Indeed these differences seem to be on the increase and indicate a divergence, even a polarization, among the various regions of Europe, with marked divides North - South, East -West. This trend is contrary to the objective pursued by the Union to promote a gradual convergence among the national systems, if not an harmonization of their main features.
The need to revise the traditional social policies has not ceased after the crisis, because the factors which challenge the traditional way of intervening in employment and industrial relations issues have proved to persist even with the economic recovery, so confirming their structural character.
Changing protective labor legislation: simplifications and flexibility
In this paper I will analyze some changes of European labor regulations and policies which appear to be particularly significant in showing the capacity of our systems to respond and to adapt to the transformation of the world of work and where the European experience may be useful for comparative analysis.
I am aware that labor law and public institutions acting in the area of employment, Industrial Relations and welfare are a limited part of the economic and social order; consequently they have a partial impact on the functioning of our systems. But thought our history State policies have always been important, if not decisive, in shaping employment relations, and in general, to regulate the power relations between labor and capital. My assumption is that their capacity to respond to the new challenges is still important for the future of work. The role of national States, altough limited by globalization, remains essential in regulating major social issues, and indeed also in influencing the trend and impact of globalization.
I am convinced that detailed analyses of specific labor regulations and policies in different areas are necessary to give full account of the often contradictory changes occurring in the complex scenarios of our discipline and of the capacity of the various systems to adapt to the external shocks and transformations. General macroeconomic and macro political observations may be insufficient if not misleading.
The complexity of present changes, which involve different policies, different actors and different levels of governance and regulations, can be fully understood only with in depth comparative and multidisciplinary research. Indeed the elements and results now acquired are in my view far from being uniform and conclusive.
The European countries have followed different strategies to fight the crisis and then to face the new world scenario depending on their social and political conditions. A common remark by comparatists is that the search for effective innovative policies is still open and proceeds with more uncertainties than with defined targets.
Most issues receive controversial or contradictory opinions and solutions. I will present here only a few of these issues and answers, with the focus on some critical areas for the future of our discipline, where the European experience may be useful to other countries.
A first controversial area has to do with the scope and the content of protective labor legislation.
In fact the intensity and rigidity of labor legislations of most European countries have been accused of producing negative effects on economic efficiency and dynamism, even though the evidence is controversial and far from conclusive.
One reaction of many national legislators has been to try to simplify labor regulations and make them more selective and tailored to the different needs and positions of the employees, including those working with non standards contracts. A common trend was to implement a new regulatory approach, more simplified and better finalized, with the declared aim of mitigating the dualism of the labor markets.
Another common trend has been to respond to the need of the enterprises to adapt to the new competitive and technological scenario, by introducing and regulating various forms of flexibility.
Numerical and external flexibility has been increased in two main directions: by reducing the sanctions for unjust dismissals and consequently their cost, by recognizing flexible types of employment contracts different from the typical employment contract for indefinite period. The extent of these changes and their impact on workers stability has been different according to the measures adopted by the various States in order to regulate the forms of flexibility.
Sheer deregulation has not been the rule; most often the law has been reducing some aspects of legal rigidity while maintaining basic principles and protections of the workers: e.g. the principle of just cause for the justification of dismissals.
An important variable has been the capacity of the unions to control the use of flexibility by the employers.
The power of the Unions has been affected to a different degree according to the economic and political context of the various States.
In most countries it has been reduced as shown by the main relevant indicators: decreasing Union density and reduced rate of conflict, shrinking collective bargaining coverage and decentralization of bargaining structure.
But still major differences persist among countries. The rate of unionization varies from a maximum of 67-70% of the Northern Countries to a low of 7.7 % (France) and the dispersion around the average rate has been growing.
In some countries (Germany, Belgium and also Italy) the power of the unions remains considerable not only at the national level but also, and some time even more, at the company level where workers representatives of various kind maintain well defined rights of participation and control.
The European policy of flexicurity: different national implementations
The risk of the increased flexibility and its impact on workers stability have been denounced by the unions of many countries and by international organizations like the ILO, which have stressed the need to regulate the use of flexibility in order to make it compatible with decent work.
A major policy suggested by the EU in a specific set of guidelines on “flexicurity”, which may be interesting for other systems, has been intended to compensate the negative effects of flexibility by introducing or reinforcing various measures aimed at protecting and assisting all displaced workers. The measures consist not only in monetary subsides to these workers but in active policies (placement services, training and retraining), intended to facilitate their reentry into the labor market. The effectiveness of these measures to keep the balance between flexibility and security has been uneven. It has been better maintained in some countries (central - Northern Europe) well equipped with active labor policies and with strong welfare systems. Lacking these conditions, the balance has been precarious and the measures aimed at workers security have not protected them from the risks of unemployment.
The economic crisis of the last decade has increased the difficulty to keep this balance, particularly to protect and assist-the displaced workers for the time necessary, for their reinstatement. For this reason the European Parliament has proposed a reframing of the policy of flexicurity. Here too some of these new policies may offer suggestions for other national systems.
Some European countries have introduced or reinforced measures aimed at preventing as much as possible the dismissals of employees of firms hit by economic crisis or involved in restructuring processes. A major provision has been to guarantee the payment of an indemnity, up to 60- 60% of the salary by social security institutions to the employees suspended by their employers for those reasons. This financed suspension, which in some cases could last up to 3-4 years, has allowed the employers to pass the bad times or to restructure their firms without mass dismissals.
Another measure adopted has been to grant to employers a wide discretion to introduce flexible working time and to change job assignments to their employees. This increased flexibility has been often accompanied by the duty, fixed by law or by collective agreements, to retrain the employeer to the new posts.
This form of functional flexibility, particularly when introduced in agreement with workers representatives, has proved useful in reducing the recourse to alternative measures of external flexibility such as outsourcing and use of temporary fixed term contracts. In a few cases it has also contributed to improve both the working conditions and productivity. These practices are being analyzed by a research group organized by the ISLSSL.
A redefinition of scope and contents is necessary for the institutions dealing not only with labor problems but also with the area of social security and welfare. A more active set of policies is needed both to reduce the increasing costs of social benefits and to mobilize the capacities of users, in order to promote their personal development and not simply to assist them in case of need.
An opportunity to be caught is to exploit the potentials of individuals, and even of individualism, by supporting personal trajectories in the various life cycles and by investing in the different personal qualities of people as to shape their “capabilities”. In this perspective welfare measures can are to be seen more than a cost as a social investment, and can prove to be not only compatible but functional to sustainable growth and to competitiveness.
This new approach to welfare measures may facilitate their extension beyond the traditional coverage of core employees to non standard workers and to the growing number of migrant workers which have been so far excluded from protection and mostly ignored.
A major challenge to the welfare systems even of the rich countries is posed by the growth of inequalities and of poverty among the various sectors of the population, including workers.
Specific measures of income support and of personal assistance for poor workers and families have been introduced in many European countries, combined with targeted labor and training policies aimed at activating the beneficiaries. Proposals of extending assistance measures or provisions of the basic income have been deemed inacceptable for their costs but also because they tend to obscure the value of work and the importance of employment policies.
The impact of the digital revolution on the future of work
These measures, like most employment practices, have now to face the challenges posed by the digital revolution which is introducing profound transformations both in the organization of work (telework, on demand employment via digital platforms) and in the structure of the enterprises.
Like most innovations, industry 4.0 implies new risks and opportunities: risks for the conditions of work (increasing stress and psychological diseases, deskilling, etc.) but also opportunities for better work- life balance and for improving the autonomy and the personalization of work.
The impact of digital revolution on the future quantity of jobs is quite controversial.
Platform- based work has still limited applications. In Europe it accounts for no more than 1% of employment; but in the US this percentage is already higher.
In any case this digital work has great potential to grow. Already a significant number of jobs have been made redundant by the spreading of ICT, particularly in some sectors like banking once considered to be the home of stability. But whatever the possible impact of these technologies, the key challenge for us, as T. Kochan rightly points out, is to find policies capable to influence the future of technologies in constructive ways. These policies are complex and not yet well defined.
It is worth mentioning that the digital threat has reopened, at least in Europe, the debate not only on work time flexibility but also on the reduction of working time. Part time (not always voluntary) is increasing and becoming a common way of redistributing work, often within the family. In the Netherlands it accounts for around half of the working population. A recent German collective agreement has recognized the right of all employees to reduce temporarily (for 2 years) their weekly working time to 28 hours (with some wage reduction) and the parallel right to return to the number of hours previously worked (35). The employers in exchange are allowed greater flexibility in the distribution of weekly working time. This agreement is considered not only in Germany a example of flexibility beneficial to both parties.
Other collective agreements particularly in the sectors most exposed to the digital revolution, have provided that a certain number of working hours, regularly paid, must be devoted to training and retaining in order to prevent technological obsolescence.
This indeed is a requirement common to all sectors of any country, since it is necessary to cope with technological innovations. More time and resources will have to be devoted to education and training of employees, not only at the early stages of their working career and during the apprenticeship, but in the entire course of their life.
Some European countries like Italy, in order to promote this policy, are combining strong fiscal incentives to the introduction of new technologies in the enterprise with parallel incentives to the training of the workers exposed to these technologies. An objective present in the European debate but worth considering also in other countries, is that all employment contracts should become educational contacts, i.e. should enrich the basic exchange of the contract: work versus wage, with a further element, namely with a certain amount of specific training.
Adaptation to changing working patterns
Whatever the quantitative evolution of work might be in the near
future, certainly most working patterns, including flexible works adopted so far, will have to change; and equally widespread changes will be necessary for the personal skills required for performing the new jobs.
The very concept of working time as traditionally framed is being altered in the digital organization of work. The on line connection necessary for the digital employees may blur the distinction between time for work and time for life, with negative implications for the personal wellbeing (risk for the heath and danger of self exploitation). Rigid legal limitations of working time are unfeasible or easy to be circumvented. New measures, legal and collective, may be necessary. Some suggestions may come from recent European practices.
Some collective agreements in Germany and the legislators in France and Italy have introduced the so called “right to disconnection” i.e. the right of employees to cease to be available on line in certain period of the day and of the night (taking into account the different time zones where digital workers may operate) and have provided the consequent duty of the employer to disconnect the server.
The digitalization of the work process requires innovations in two other critical areas of labor law and labor policies: health and safety regulation, and protection of employees privacy. Both represent common challenges to all advanced economies. The need to prevent and remedy not only the physical risks known to the industrial reduction but other psychological disorders which are already increasing in the information society, has been recognized by some countries which have reframed their legislation on health and safety as to include the new risks.
New risks for health and safety, and for personal privacy
The national Institutes in charge of work accidents have begun to adapt the requisites and the tariffs for the relevant insurance to the peculiar conditions of remote work.
Moreover some national legislators (including Italy) have enacted specific regulations to protect workers privacy and business operations and secrecy.
All enterprises are required to implement procedural rules, under the responsibility of plant managers, aimed at preventing any use of digital devices capable of violating employees privacy (violations are severely sanctioned). Any use of devices which can control employees activity must be approved by workers representatives and/ or by the labor inspectors; moreover the data collected through these devices cannot be ground for disciplinary sanctions against the employees. A controversial issue is how to regulate the use of devices which are necessary for performing the job and at the same time may indirectly control employees activity. The management practices will have to be carefully monitored in order to clarify this issue and possibly to adapt the regulations to the evolution of technological devices.
The conditions of work created by the new forms of business organization which are often more demanding than in the past, and the new needs and aspirations of present employees have stimulated an increased demand of quality in working life.
Search for a better work-life balance
In response to this demand many collective agreements signed at the firm level in quite a few European countries have devoted greater attention to controlling the implementation of technological innovations and to preventing their negative effects on working conditions. The impact of these collective regulations has ben favored by various forms of workers participation to the process of innovation, which in some countries have been supported by legislation.
A parallel trend of some agreements has been to introduce positive measures not only for improving health and safety but also for promoting a better work life balance.
To this end they have introduced personal and family friendly working time, and various kind of benefits supplementing public welfare aimed at fostering the wellbeing of people at work (care services for kids and aged relatives, support to children education and leisure, medical assistance and pensions more generous that those provided by the state).
The number of these agreements has been growing (in Italy they are counted by the thousands) also because they have been promoted by fiscal advantages which exempt from taxation most welfare benefits agreed upon with the unions. A reduced taxation has also been provided on wages linked to various indicators of productivity indicated by collective agreements. The rationale, which has been accepted by the Unions, is to promote a wage structure less rigid than in the past and more conducive to productivity.
Moreover the same Italian legislation has provided a further fiscal prize when these productivity bonuses and welfare benefits are accompanied with forms of workers participation in the organization of work within the firms, through bilateral committee with employers representatives.
This promotional legislation has contributed to diffuse workers participation in the enterprise. This kind of participation is quite common in countries like Germany and France and is promoted by specific European directive (2001/8 and regulation 2157/2001) but was so far resisted in Italy, mainly for ideological reasons.
The workers of the gig economy: problems of categorization and of protection
The information technologies and the digital economy have contributed to multiply the forms of work, which require new legal and contractual regulations.
The rules adopted in the European countries are variable but have in common the tendency mentioned above to give more space than in the past to flexibility. Equally common is the recognition that the traditional categorization of employment contracts is not adequate to fully reflect the content of many “atypical” contracts which have emerged in the mobile labor market of today. Even the basic demarcation between subordinate employment and self employment is becoming less and less clear.
The platform -based work is an exemplar case.
European legislators have introduced various measures to regulate the new contracts, most often-with the aim of mitigating the fragmentation and the dualism of the labor market. The criteria for identifying subordination have been loosely interpreted by some courts. Quite a few social protection are being extended to atypical contracts. Various mechanisms, mixed of incentives and controls, have been experimented in order to formalize informal work (which is widely present also in our countries).
A relatively new type of workers has been growing who are not legally subordinate but neither are fully autonomous, because they are economically dependent on one or a few principals. The legislators of some countries have created an intermediate category of contracts with various names: quasi subordinate employees (Italy), employee -like persons (Germany) or workers (UK). To these employees some but not all the rules of labor law apply: mainly those concerning social security, health and safety, minimum wages and other minimum standards, rights of association and of collective bargaining.
The various forms of digital works present in the gig economy have posed new problems of categorization, because these employees often combine traits typical of both dependent and independent work. These problems have been so far mostly handled by the national courts in hundreds of cases, which have received divergent solutions. In quite a few cases, mainly involving Uber drivers or the “riders” of Foudora, the courts have considered them as employees, even when not all traditional indicators of subordination were present. Other courts have included them in the intermediate category mentioned above. Sometime the judges have recognized the hybrid character of their work in order to grant some but not all the protections of labor law. The need to recognize some basic protections to these workers has prevailed over the uncertainty of the legal qualification of the contract.
A similar approach has been adopted by the French legislator in 2016 (Act. August 8, 2016, n. 1088, art. 6). While giving a rather general definition of digital workers, this Act has provided that they are entitled to some basic rights such as the right to continuos education and training, to the protection against work accidents; the right of association, of collective bargaining and of strike. The European court of justice has stated that Uber is not a mere platform for the intermediation of work, but an enterprise involved in transport and logistic activities. Consequently it is obliged to follow the national rules on these activities, not necessarily those concerning labor matters (but the road is open to consider also labor regulations).
The issue is still controversial, particularly because the typology of activities organized in the gig economy is highly differentiated and variable. E.g. the criteria applied to Uber drivers do not fit to many crowd workers who perform minute and short tasks through personal access to digital platforms, which do not exercise any kind of interference nor direction of their activities.
The impact of change on labor unions and collective agreements
The changes of the economic context and the diversification of work require a reappraisal not only of public employment policies but also of collective bargaining and industrial relations. How to do it is a controversial issue which has received different solutions also by those, governments and social parties, who consider collective bargaining and industrial relations an important form of social participation and of employees protection and not an obstacle to the functioning of the economy.
Collective agreement, have been shaped, like statutory law, according to the dominant patterns of standard employment and mostly based on the experience of the social parties of industrialized countries. If they are to remain a major source of regulation of employment, they too must revise their objectives and practices so as to respond to the diversification of employment patterns, and on the other hand to the globalization of markets.
Indeed these transformations are affecting the system Industrial Relations even more directly than the legal status of the contract of employment, in so far as industrial relations are exposed in many cases, without any protection, to the pressures of the markets, and because the diversification of work affects the very basis of collective action of the workers, more than the initiatives of the employers.
These factors have altered the power relations among the social parties to the detriment of the labor unions and account for the growing difficulties of traditional Industrial Relations which are visible even in the strongest systems of central and Northern Europe.
However here too the responses of the various national relations are far from uniform as it is shown by the main indicators.
The everage union density, while in general declining, varies from the still high levels of the Scandinavian countries and Belgium to the lowest of France, Spain.
In countries like Italy it seems to have stabilized (around 31.8). Moreover the national variations of union density around the average in these years have increased in all European states, which supports a possible trend toward divergence or even polarization more than toward convergence.
Moreover the decline of overage union density and the even more pronounced decline of industrial conflict which has been confined to the public sector, are not fully reflected in the coverage and in the structure of collective bargaining. Here the variations among countries are different from those of Union density due to the impact of other factors, in particular of legislation and of public policies concerning industrial relations.
The coverage of national collective agreements has continued to be relatively high also in countries where the rate of unionization has been traditionally low such as France and Spain, and has further declined in recent years. This is due mainly to State legislations which have supported the application of national or multi employer collective agreements beyond the area of unions influence by way of various mechanism of legal extension of these agreements to all the firms and employees of the various economic sectors.
This promotional legislation has not been changed, and indeed has been reinforced in some countries like Germany: while in the past the extension could be decided on the condition that the agreement covered the majority of the interested firms and employees, recent legislation has lifted this condition, to facilitate the extension. It has provided that the extension can be ordered at request of the bargaining parties following a discretionary evaluation of the public authorities.
Moreover minimum wages have been introduced in Germany, one of the few countries of Europe, together with Italy, where they did not exist as a way to sustain the salaries of occasional and precarious types of work, so called mini jobs, which are much lower than the average.
Even in the countries like Italy where a legal system of extension does not exist, other forms of indirect support of the effects of the agreements are in place. Courts decisions and administrative provisions require the respect of the standards fixed by national agreements as a condition to receive various fiscal benefits. The same wage standards are relevant to determine the basis for social security contributions. The role and effectiveness of collective agreements have been indirectly sustained also by the law which recognize the right to bargain only to some representative unions, in order to oppose the fragmentation and hence the weakening of the bargaining parties.
These legal interventetions have been important in supporting collective agreements; even though it is doubtful that they may be sufficient to redress the balance of power which is now unfavourable for the unions.
Another significant example of promotional legislation has been adopted by some countries, and endorsed by an EU directive which grants consultation and participation rights to workers representatives on major enterprise decisions affecting working conditions. The experience of countries where this participation is widely adopted has shown positive results not only in facilitating employment relations, but also in improving both the welfare of workers and the productivity of firms. This approach however requires a major change of attitude in the culture and practice of the social parties, particularly of the unions most dedicated to conflict and often alien to participation. An institutional support to participative Industrial Relations comes also in those countries where unions and employers associations have developed, with legal endorsement, a net of bilateral committees and organizations which administer a considerable number of welfare and training instruments. These bilateral institutions have resisted to the economic crisis and to the changes of government.
11. Decentralization of collective bargaining structure
The transformation of work and of the markets have exerted strong pressure to decentralize the structure of collective bargaining which in quite a few European countries was rather centralized, given the central position of national sectorial agreements.
Decentralized bargaining, mainly to the company and plant level, has acquired a decisive role in most countries even where the national and multi employer agreements were traditionally prevalent (se research group n. 4 of the ISLSSL).
The national legislators have encouraged this process of decentralization on various conditions and with a different impact on the role of national agreements. Some legislations (Spain) has completely altered the traditional hierarchy of the bargaining structure by attributing to company agreements the primary role in regulating most labor issues, including the possibility to fix conditions of work less favorable to employees than those set nationally. A more nuanced solution has been adopted in France where the law has attributed to decentralized agreements priority in the regulation of some issues not reserved to national agreements; but it has provided the duty of the employers to bargain periodically over most labor matters.
Similar measures have been decided, although less clearly, by Italian law, which has recognized to decentralized agreements, contrary to tradition, the same legal status and effectiveness as the national agreements. Moreover collective bargaining has been promoted in specific areas, because some fiscal incentives have been reserved to productivity bonuses and to welfare benefits bargained with the unions, and not to those unilaterally decided by management.
In countries like Germany and Italy the central labor unions have been able to control the process of decentralization, at least in the strong economic sectors and in medium large firms; and have used the possibility to derogate from the national standards mainly in cases of serious economic crisis in order to prevent mass dismissals and plant closures.
In sum these trends indicate a marked alteration of the structure of continental collective bargaining. The national agreements are becoming similar to framework contracts setting basic standards and guidelines more than regulating the actual conditions of work. Wages tend to be linked, above the minima, to the performance of workers and to indicators of business productivity and results.
Decentralized agreements tend to become firm specific i.e. dedicated to solve problems of work organization and to administer the daily life of the workplace, mostly through specialized procedures and bilateral committees. In many advanced companies participatory bargaining is competing with innovative HR management for the allegiance of the new and old types of employees.
For the reasons already explained public support to collective activities is important even more than in the past. But the future of the industrial relations depends in the first place on the capacity of the labor movement to find new reasons and objectives for a common action.
The growth and influence of the European unions have been built, differently from the trend prevailing in the USA, not only on collective bargaining, but on a vast spectrum of social and political actions ranging from participation within the enterprises and in public institutions in charge of labor policies, training and welfare policies.
The value of this multiplicity of arenas in face of the present transformations, has been confirmed by most European unions, even though their relations with the traditional labor parties has been loosened, and the declining fortunes of labor friendly governments have often reduced their financial and institutional support to unions activities.
The decline of membership and the increasingly difficult relationship with the State and public institutions have persuaded many European unions to experiment innovative forms of recruiting activities similar to those practiced by american unions, in particular towards the new types of employees, skilled and unskilled, which populate the present labor markets.
But these practices of union-revitalization have met with uneven degree of success, due the difficulty to overcome the obstacles which contrast collective action and organizations.
Forms of collaboration and alliance with other types of social movement have been searched by some unions; but in most cases have remained at an initial stage, due to the difficulty to find common objectives with the traditional goals and often to the resistance of the unions leadership.
In fact greater attention has been given by the unions of the major countries to service activities of different kinds (social assistance, training services) which have proved useful not only to increase the allegiance of members and the attractiveness of membership but also to compensate for the reduced amount of member dues and of public resources.
This decentralization process has been promoted by employers associations, but they have not pushed to abolish national and multi employer bargaining, in this respect converging with the position of the unions. Workers organizations are committed to safeguard the social function of national agreements as guarantee of equality in the basic conditions of work for all the employees of the same economic sectors. The employers associations have accepted to maintain this level of bargaining even though reduced in content and made more flexible, in order to respond to the different needs of the firms, because national agreements have proved to be useful to regulate employment contracts of the multitude of small firms, often marginal, which represent the majority in many sectors of the economy. They have been useful also to exempt these firms from the direct impact of unions and of social pressure. At the same time national agreements leaves room to the more productive enterprises to regulate differently their employees according to their specific needs.
12. Global Trade and fundamental rights: the social clauses in international treaties
A different challenge to traditional labor regulations comes from the diffusion of work and of the enterprises on a global scale. This challenge is often combined with or intensified by the innovations coming from the new technologies, because these technologies multiply the possibility to expand most activities beyond the national borders.
The challenge goes to the roots of our discipline, because our legal systems, particularly those concerning labor relations, have been nationally based and have been created and supported by national policies and regulations. This has occurred often in agreement with the social parties. These issues are object of the research group n. 3 of the ISLSSL.
The unions have recently tried to expand their organization and some activities, including strike action at the supranational level. But the resources devoted to these activities are still limited and have not brought to the international workers representatives sufficient power to face the great influence of multinational enterprises.
The need to face this new scenario and to project internationally labor regulations and social policies is widely recognized. But more political and intellectual investments are necessary to change the contents and techniques of national regulations and policies in order to enable them to operate effectively across national borders. The objective of international labor regulations
is not only to protect the increasing number of people who work across the borders, but also to defend the national standards of work from unfair competition of the firms operating in foreign countries. Part of the challenge is that the law is called to reconcile the commercial logic of trade with the need to guarantee basic social rights of workers involved in international trade.
All the national actors, public institutions, employers associations and labor unions, together with the relevant international organizations, have been trying to respond to this challenge and have adopted different techniques to shape supranational principles and regulations.
The complexity of the issues involved and the variety of the actors of international trade has given rise to a diversification of forms of regulation: directives and recomendations of international organizations (ILO, OECD in the first place); social clauses inserted in international treaties; general systems of preference (GSP); codes of practices of multinational enterprises; transnational collective agreements.
The difference of these sources and of the matters affected has brought about an extreme variety of contents and techniques of regulation, plus different systems of implementation.
The whole spectrum of regulatory systems developed in past national and international experiences has found here a fertile ground of application.
The European Union and its member States have attempted to promote the international respect of some basic labor standards, through the insertion of social clauses in multinational trade agreements and with other instruments such as the GSP.
A similar objective is pursued by other multilateral agreements signed in different areas of the world (the TPP for the pacific countries). Interesting innovations are present in a recent trade agreement signed between the European Union and Canada (Ceta). The CETA commits the parties, with rather assertive language, to observe the fundamental principles and rules stated by the ILO conference of 1998, and also the right to strike (a rather unique case in trade agreements).
An innovative solution is provided concerning the procedures for the implementation of the social clause, which is usually the weakest part of trade agreements. The CETA establishes not only bilateral consultations among the parties to solve the disputes, like in most other agreements, but also a review panel of experts and civil society advisory groups entitled to submit opinions and recommendations. Moreover national labor inspectors are charged to control the implementation of the social clause. In case of non acceptance of the judgment of the experts the claimant can suspend the obligations of the treaty of equivalent importance or ask for monetary compensation as indicated by the panel.
The CETA has set up a specialized tribunal composed of impartial members enabled to adjudicate the disputes with private investors arising under the treaty. This innovation is meant to correct the common procedures under the ISDS clauses which have proved to be rather biased in favor of the investors.
12. Other vehicles of supranational regulations: codes of conduct and transnational collective agreements
Another set of supranational rules has been adopted by many multinational enterprises of European origin which have formalized codes of conduct referring to the fundamental rights and standards approved by the ILO. Similar codes are being adopted by multinationals of different nationality. These codes have in common that they are legally not binding, but they set guidelines to be observed by all the units of the company and of the enterprise group, including those operating in countries different from the home country. In some cases the respect of the guidelines is subject to external monitoring, but the independence of the monitoring is often uncertain. The effectiveness of the codes may depend more than on their force on the pressures of public opinion and of social organizations which often denounce the violations of the codes and so put in danger the reputation of the company.
Some European multinationals, influenced by the continental social model, have decided to consult the unions or to negotiate with them the content of the codes. In a few cases formal agreements have been signed with the European works councils which are the workers representative body present in many countries and promoted by a specific European directive (2009/38).
The number of transnational agreements signed with the works councils and with the unions has been growing. These agreements have expanded their contents so as to improve the fundamental labor standards and to treat broad social and welfare issues.
The multiplication of these agreements has been favored by the trend to decentralize industrial relations to the company level which is common to many countries, not only european. The accords concluded with the works councils may be more effective than the sectional agreements signed with the unions, because they can be implemented directly also across the borders by the decision of the company who is party to the agreement. A limit of all these agreements is that they do not have a common legal status in the different European countries. Moreover the employers associations and the unions who sign the international agreements do not have sufficient supranational powers to monitor and to enforce them. This limit is common to the representative associations operating in most countries of the world.
The question of the legal enforcement of supranational agreements has received hardly any direct test, because the parties tend to solve the disputes arising under the agreement through their own channels (grievance procedures or the like). The national tribunals have been reluctant to decide labor cases arising in other countries, i.e. to admit an extraterritorial application of national labor laws.
A few pilot cases, mainly originated in the USA, are interesting as possible examples of a new courts attitude. E.g. a suit was brought by a Korean Union against a firm for a dismissal decided in violation of a collective agreement and was taken to a court in New York where the mother company of the Korean firm was accused of interference with the local management. The court acknowledged the violation of the agreement but did not sanctions the mother company alleging a procedural exception. In spite of this unsatisfactory result the court decision many open the way to the possible enforcement of contractual obligations against multinational companies located in a country other than that where the violation occurred.
The enforcement may be easier when the supranational agreements are concluded by European multinationals operating in Europe. The courts of European states might be inclined to consider favorably cases concerning contracts or facts occurred in nearby countries, if somehow linked to events relevant their territory, because they have been used to enforce regulations which derive from the authorities of the Union and which compose a supranational legal order.
A recent example of the European supranational order comes from a directive, to be approved by the European Parliament, which is intended to fight social dumping among member states. Also this problem is common to countries of other areas of the world.
The European solution may be interesting. In fact the directive (Directive 96/71, to be revised) provides that the employees working in a place different from the home country of the employer are entitled to the same basic standards applied to the local employees (wages, social security, main working conditions).
The European interventions in favor of the member States is not limited to legal regulations such as the directives. Various forms of social policies which are expression of supranational solidarity are in place. It is worth mentioning in particular quite a few programs financed with European funds aimed at responding to the most serious social problems present in Europe: a program for supporting youth employment; various so called “structural funds” aimed at promoting local development, particularly in the least developed areas; a special fund which can support financially and with personal assistance the employees who are “victims' of globalization” (Reg. 1927/2006 instituting the FEG, 546/2009); the program “industry 4.0” which promotes private and public investments in technological innovation and in the necessary training of employees.
These measures, which have been experimented in other regional areas, have proved useful in improving the relations among different nations, with concrete aids, financial and institutional. They have the advantage that can be implemented gradually and be adopted to the policy priorities of the interested communities.
A common limit of supranational rules depend on the fact that they are not sustained by the authority of State institutions and apparatus which have supported for centuries the binding effect of the law. The actors involved here are at least three: the international organizations, the national States, and the Multinationals. The former institutions have no direct legislative powers and their enforcement mechanisms are largely dependent on national States and on social parties which are reluctant to delegate to them more binding powers.
The national States are still important actors, even though threatened by globalization. But so far they have not fully invested in supporting the implementation of supranational rules, particularly in employment and social matters.
The multinational enterprises have acquired a major importance in international affairs and their influence is far greater than that exerted by the weak international projections of social parties, labor unions in particular.
Moreover the regulation of social and employment relations is not the primary objective of these companies and is largely independent from public influence.
Improving the quality and the effectiveness of transnational social regulations is not a merely technical task. It would require a change in the strategy of the various actors. The enterprises should accept more stringent social obligations than those resulting from the codes of practice. The States could require the enterprises to abide by the same social standards included in the trade agreements and/or to give binding force to the principles of corporate social responsibility.
But most important, they should give priority in their political agenda to supporting the presence and the influence of social rules in international relations.
13. Uncertain prospects of labor regulations: the role of the States and of European institutions
This brief overview of European experiences presents a very diversified scenario. Not only the specific measures but the very approach to our discipline have profoundly changed in the last decade. In many cases the policy innovations have altered the fundamental traits of the established patterns of labor law and industrial relations. These change do not justify the widespread opinion that considers our discipline a sclerotic area of social sciences.
The examples drawn from the various European constituencies confirm and indeed stress the diversity of the solutions adopted to meet the challenges to which the world of work is confronted. The diversity, even the polarization, between the various labor policies and regulations have significant influence on the national social and economic systems and may be considered as contributing to the varieties of capitalism.
It is uncertain whether these innovations, even the most successful, will be sufficient to counteract the negative factors which have contributed to the decline of unions powers, of collective bargaining and to the weakening of labor rights.
The evaluations by experts and politicians of the possible impact of these measures are divergent and not yet conclusive.
As I mentioned above they range from those which envisage a neoliberal convergence of most social and legal systems, which implies a reduced capacity to protect the rights of workers, to different opinions which consider the present changes as a necessary adaptation of the traditional regulatory and welfare measures to new global and technological conditions. According to this latter opinion the legal and social innovations represent not a simple retrenchment, but a repositioning of our social and legal systems necessary to face the present challenges and to defend, if not all the acquired rights of the core workers, the essential standards of decent work for the persons who perform the various activities, often atypical, present in the mobile labor markets of today.
The implications of the measures implemented by the European States are also uncertain. Adopting different measures in the various countries, and even within the same country in the various economic sectors and areas, may be necessary to match the measures to the diversity of the factual conditions. To some extend it may correspond to the increased complexity of our social and economic systems.
But most critics emphasize the risk that this trend might lead to a stable dualism of legal and industrial relations regimes and contradict the mission of our discipline to promote social justice and progress for all.
In any case the examples presented here confirm the importance of the initiative of the national states and of the national social actors in determining the major trends of labor and industrial relations. Their strategies can make the difference even in the present global scenario.
Indeed some States are reasserting their authority in labor regulations and resisting to the global pressures in response to the denounce by their constituencies of the danger of globalization.
The success of these initiatives will depend on the conditions of the various States but also on their capacity to innovate the policy mix in the directions exemplified above: e.g. a more selective use of legislation concentrated on basic standard to be applied universally, a better balance between flexibility in the firms and security in the labor market, supported with active labor policies and income guarantees; increased investments in basic and digital education and in continuous training; promotion of new forms of workers participation in the enterprise and of unions involvement in the administration of social security and placement services.
In Europe the institutions of the European Union have exerted significant influence also in the area of labor regulations and welfare, using many instruments, often indirect but more stringent than those available to other supranational and international institutions.
The policies of the Union have been changing in the years. Recently they have given priority to safeguarding financial stability with austerity measures even at the expenses of policies necessary to support economic growth.
The economic government of the European Union following this priority has influenced in various degrees the decisions of members states in economic and social matters. In the States most endangered by financial and economic crisis its decisions have severely limited the capacity to freely determine the most important public policies and have forced them to implement drastic forms of internal devaluation.
The reactions of the public opinion have provoked social and political repercussions in many countries (including the rise of anti- European movements). These reactions may have contributed to the recent proposals of the European Commission envisaging a reorientation of its priority towards growth enhancing policies.
It remains to be seen if and to what extent this new approach will materialize and will produce significant changes in labor policies and regulations. Even experts not prejudiced against the Union are skeptical, and forecast that a possible reaction to further inertia of the European institutions may be the revival of nationalism also in labor regulations.
I am convinced thath labor regulations are an important elements of the social order. If well framed they can positively contribute to competitiveness and sustainable development. But as already mentioned good regulations and social policies are only one contributing factor to this end. The whole range of public policies must be finalized to the objective of creating a more inclusive and sustainable growth. The economic and financial strategies adopted by the States and by the European Union will have a decisive influence also on our field.
Compila il seguente form. Ti risponderemo il prima possibile!