The paper discusses the impact of new technologies on the legal categories of labor law and proposes a new approach to the regulation of work.
1. Content of the paper
In this presentation we will select (concentrate) four mains areas where the transformations of work have a major impact on labor law and labor policies:
- The regulations of the new non standard types of employment.
- The relevance of the diversification of work for social security.
- The regulation of workers mobility in the labor market.
- The role of industrial relations in the new (digital) economy.
2. A general introduction
Labor law and Industrial Relations are challenged by the great transformation of the present economy and society.
The impact of these transformations is controversial. Some analyses predict radical changes not only in the quantity and quality of future employment, but in the very essence of our discipline: namely a universal neoliberal transformations of industrial relations and an irreversible decline of the legal and collective regulation of employment.
Comparative research gives some evidence that the impact is not predetermined, but is influenced by the existing institutions and by the political decisions adopted in different times and in various countries.
Indeed the reactions of the various national systems of I will concentrate on the European experience) and the measures implemented by them to react to this critical scenario have been different; and the differences seen to be on the increase, contrary to the assumption of a gradual convergence among the national systems.
An open alternative concerns the content of these measures: are they specific adoptations of the traditional legal system sufficient to restore this role and efficientiveness, or is it necessary a radical change of “paradigm”. In fact most European examples seen to be of the former type.
The European approach is a significant testing ground for detecting the reactions of labor law and industrial relations to the transformations of the world of work. The analysis of these reactions may also offer some arguments to test verify the opinions mentioned above which envisage an inevitable decline of Industrial Relations.
The various European states have different social and legal traditions, but the European Union has contributed to spread common practices and rules in the field of employment and industrial relations, which have built a common social dimension, usually named “social model”.
Relative to most other areas of the world this 'model' is characterized by high standards in the major aspects of labor regulations: guarantees of collective and individual social rights, statutory legal and collective regulations.
In spite of its achivements, the established system of social rights and policies has not fully protected the European workers and citizens from the damages of the recent economic crisis.
3. The impact of new technologies on the legal categories
The paper will discuss here some of the major challenges which the tranformations of the world of work are posing to labor law and social policies.
A major challenge comes from the impact of the new technologies, in particular digital, on the quantity and quality of work.
Forecast that most traditional jobs will disappear in the near future are probably exaggerated. Yet the impact is bound to grow.
In any case the effects of digital innovations on employment are bound to grow, especially in traditional repetitive jobs.
It is significant that, in Europe, the threat from the digital revolution has re-opened the debate not only on flexible working hours, but also on their reduction. The recently renegotiated contract of German metalworkers entitles them to reduce (for two years) their weekly working hours to 28 (with a partial reduction in salary) or, if they prefer, to return to a normal working week of 35 hours. In return, the employers are permitted to exercise greater flexibility in organizing working time. Part-time working (not always voluntary) is on the increase, emerging as a widespread system of work-sharing, often within the family.
The forms and quality of work will certainly be affected by unprecedetecd change leading particularly where repetitive work is concerned, leading to the polarization of jobs. The change is so profound that the inadequacy not only of traditional regulations but even of the categories on which labour law are based is becoming evident, first and foremost subordinate employment.
The various forms of platform - based employment are an extreme example of the insufficience of the traditional categories of labor contracts.
It is significant that the regulation of these forms has proved quite controversial and have received different responses by national legislators, by judges and even by social parties. Some responses are inclined to include gig economy workers. In the category of the subordinate workers and recognize them the associated rights. Other emplasize their indipendent status. Some legislatory have created intermediate categories of employment contracts under various names: parasubordinated jobs (Italy), economically dependent employment (Spain), relations similar to subordinate employment (Germany), workers (UK).
To these contracts are applied some, but not all, of the traditional protections afforded to subordinate employees: in particular, minimum wages, safety standards, social security, accident insurance, etc. But the creation of these new categories has not clarified the borderlines between them; on the contrary, it has sometimes made them difficult to identify.
I am convinced that in order to provide an adequate response, more attention should be paid to the needs of protection and of support of these new workers, instead of relying on traditional legal categories.
4. From legal categories to the modulation of protections
Such an approach is followed by the French legislator (Act August, 8, 2016, n. 1088) which has recognized to these workers a number of essential rights and protections: protection against work accidents, right to association, adequate training, etc. Not claiming to provide legal definitions of digital employment the law has abandoned the all-or-nothing logic inherent in the rigid traditional categories.
A recent Italian Act (101/2019) follows a similar approach. It adopts a rather loose definition of platform workers, avoiding precise legal qualification, which is left to labor courts. On the other Land it introduces a minimal regulation granting some rights to those workers who deliver goods (so called riders): insurance against work accidents and illness, the same protective norms on health and safety which are applicable to all workers; right to payments linked to actual delivery of the good (but not totally). Collective agreements may provide forms of payment linked to the way in which the activity is performed.
Moreover the law gives to collective bargaining the power to redefine and clarify the borders between different forms of atypical coordinates employment, while adapting the treatment to the specific requirements of individual types of work and business (Leg. Decree 81/2015, Article 2.2).
Equally significant of this approach is the ruling of the European Commission. While mentioning the possible use of subordinate employment criteria for settling so-called “platform workers” cases and disputes, the Commission merely invites member States to ensure that workers benefit from “fair working conditions” and “adequate and sustainable social protection”, identified by considering “the different needs and the innovative nature of collaborative business models”.
In any case the variable character of the new jobs suggests that rigid legal interventions are less effective that flexible regulations which can be better determined by collective agreements.
The diversification of the forms of work and their difference from the standard employment have led some authors to elaborate the notion of “ personal work relationship” and to consider it central to labor law, in lieu of the “employment contract”. This doctrine justly argues for the need to extend the application of some rights and protections beyond the borders of traditional employment to the diversified universe of the new forms of work.
But this argument should not be pushed to the point of diluting all the body of labor law into a generic and undistinct regulation valid for any type of human activity.
The real challenge for our discipline is to analyse and interpret the specific traits of the new works and the needs of the people who perform them in order to distinguish those parts of traditional labor law which are applicable to then, from these norms and policies which are irrelevant on even counter productive. Some traditional protections may loose importance for employees who have acquired great operational indipendence, even though they are hired under an employment contract. The some is true for people who work on a digital environment where the traditional limits of space and time are being blurred.
The selection of appropriate regulation is decisive and not easy to decide. This regulation should be indentified by matching the function of the different norms with the needs of protection and of promotion of the people working in different environments, taking into account of the reason of business and the objective of sustainable growth.
A similar principle is asserted in the European guidelines quoted above.
This is a general principle which should be tested on the ground according to the specific work and business context; with the caveat of avoiding both excessive rigidity for business and lack of protection for the employees. Such an approach might favour a regulatory approach not only better finalized but also more flexible and simplified. It might also reduce the legal norms of detail and increase the importance of minimum standards, national and in perspective supranational, as advocated by the “Decent Work Agenda” of the ILO.
5. Procedures instead of rigid rules: working time and job classifications
In some areas substantive norms might prove impraticable and be better substituted by procedural regulations. Two good exemple are the regulation of working time and of job qualification.
In both areas the new technologies, in particular digital, have altered the material basis on which traditional norms have been built: on one side the organization and the very notion of “time and space of work”; on the other the relations between human skills and intelligent machines.
In the former area the recent Italian legislation on the so called “smart working” (Act 81) is significant because it has abandoned the traditional approach to the regulation of working time and has left to the individual agreement between the employer and the worker the role of regulating the distribution of work time and of setting the best worklife balance (with in the maximum limits of total hours fixed by European directives).
The assumption is that this solution would favor both the need of business flexibility and a good conciliation between work time and personal needs of the employees.
While acknowleding the importance of the objective pursued by the Act, the decision to give a decisive role to the individual contract has raised quite a few objections. The fact of working in a digital environment does not increase the capacity of the individual employer to determine the conditions of work including a acritical aspect such as working timer with real autonomy vis à vis the employer.
More balanced and equitable solutions might come from some French and Italian experiences where collective agreements (mainly companywide). Instead of setting fixed rules of working time have offered to the parties a set of options (a menu) of different time schedules in which the individuals employees and employers can choose according to the circumstances and needs.
In the second area Act 81/2015 has changed the traditional rule which limited the possibility to change the jobs assigned by contract to the employee only to job positions having equivalent skill content and value (the notion of equivalence being strictly interpreted by courts).
The Act, acknowleding the difficulty to regulate by law the variable content of the present jobs and skills, has assigned to collective agreements the task to determine the rules, mainly the procedures, necessary to govern labor mobility within the firms, while safeguarding or developing the professional skills of the employees.
In both cases collective agreements are challenged to go beyond the traditional forms of rigid regulation similar to those of the law and to adopt procedural solution with a “problem solving” approach.
This new task can be adequately performed only if industrial relations are capable of interpreting the present realities of work and are supported in their functioning by the common will of the parties and by public policies (which is not always the case).
6. The European policies of flexicurity
Labor law has always been concerned with regulating the conditions of work not only in the individual employment relations but also in the labor market.
The latter function has acquired growing importance in recent years, due to the increased dynamism of labor markets and consequent greater need of mobility for both workers and enterprises. This trend has raised (or made more acute) a general policy problem: namely how to facilitate mobility on the labor market without depriving employees of the necessary protection in employment.
European directives have tradionally recognized that the need of flexibility in work has to be balanced by measures to guarantee protection and assistance to workers in the labor market.
This policy which goes under the heading of flexicurity has been officially adopted by most member states but has been implemented with different and uneven result in various countries
The essential test of effectiveness depends on the balance maintained between the two terms of the trade off, flexibility and security. This balance has been uneven. It has been better maintained in some countries (central - Northern Europe) well equipped with active labor policies and with strong welfare systems. Lacking these conditions, the balance has been precarious and the measures aimed at workers security have not always protected them from the risks of unemployment.
The economic crisis of the last decade has increased the difficulty to keep this balance, particularly to protect and assist the displaced workers for the time necessary for their reinstatement. The traditional income support provided by state agencies to workers unemployed or suspended from work due to enterprise crises, has become often insufficient to cover the periods of inactivity of these workers.
For this reason the European Parliament has proposed a reframing of the policy of flexicurity.
Some countries, beginning with Italy, have prolonged the duration of welfare support to workers suspended from work, but at high costs for public finance and with the risk of “freezing” too many employees in firms and jobs doomed to extinction and of substracting resources to investments and job creation.
Alternative policies are being experimented to provide better placement and replacement services finalized to support firms and employees in the periods of transition which are becoming a recurrent or normal feature of modern labor market.
The Italian legislator (Act -----) has decided a robust intervention aimed at strengthening these services, with considerable investments in their organization, informatic structures and skilled personnel. The priority of these measures is reserved to people in conditions of poverty which benefit from a basic income recently implemented, so called “citizen income” (see below).
This priority should not go to the detriment of two other groups in need of these services: one unemployed workers, particularly when unemployment is of long duration (a large percentage of the total); two, those in transition from different jobs who need intensive retraining.
The role of public authorities, national and mostly regional, is still decisive, even though authorized private agencies are now called to collaborate, particularly to provide special personal services.
The economic crisis has shown the limits of the traditional policy of flexicurity and has required a new approach also by firms and their management. The European Council in the document mentioned above (“The second phase of flexicurity”) has recommended to promote measures of internal flexibility with the aim of minimizing the risk of numerical flexibility, i.e. of personnel reduction.
These measures should be specified by the employer in HR provisional programs, including in particular training and retraining, targeted to the employees most exposed to technological obsolescence; and promotion internal labor mobility and organizational innovations aimed to maximize the employability of the employees. Another measure frequently adopted, also in Italy has been to grant to employers a wide discretion to introduce flexible working time and to change job assignments to their employees. This increased flexibility has been often accompanied by the duty, fixed by law or by collective agreements, to retrain the employees to the new posts.
This form of functional flexibility, particularly when introduced in agreement with workers representatives, has proved useful in reducing the recourse to alternative measures of external flexibility such as outsourcing and use of temporary fixed term contracts.
7. The challenges to social security
The welfare systems built in the last Century, which are a fundamental component of the European social model, are under stress, due to adverse convergent factors. On the one hand financial constraints are reducing the available resources, on the other the rapidly aging population (faster than anticipated) demands more resources both for pensions and health care. Moreover the low birth rate in countries like Italy threatens to dry up the sources for financing the welfare system. The old age dependency ratio (percentage of active population on the total) is already at 55% and is excepted to rise.
A reaction common to most countries has been to postpone the age of retirement, but with different speed and various exceptions in the various systems.
In particular exceptions are provided, in Italy like elsewhere, for people with various kind of disadvantages: workers who have started early their employment (in Italy, 18/19 years); employed in heavy and dangerous activities, people affected by serious invalidity; women with children.
A recent Italian Act (4/2019) has introduced a general reduction of retirement age (down from 67 to 62 ) which has been criticized for further increasing the already heavy burden of pensions on the state budget and for shifting uncreasing costs on the future generations.
A second policy recommended by the European Union is promote measures of active ageing, within the enterprises as a necessary complement to raising the retirement age.
The employers have the main responsibility for introducing various measures age friendly: eg. for adopting flexible forms of worktime, reducing work loads, refraiming career paths; targeting specific forms of training and reskilling.
Some of these initiatives of the enterprise are encouraged by state policies, which have introduced different kinds of support, eg. for the retraining of aging employees, for promoting forms of gradual retirement and exchange of expertise between young and old employees.
The major emphasis of public interventions has been to guarantee the financial sustainability of the welfare systems, in particular of pensions and this has gone often to the detriment of the adequacy of the measures to meet the (growing) needs of the beneficiaries.
A policy common to most European countries for sustaining the adequacy of pensions has been to support with public incentives various forms of supplementary pensions, in order to build a second pillar of the system. In Italy pension funds set up by collective agreements cover 7.9 million employees in the private sector (2017); funds providing health care supplementary to the public system cover 10.6 million employees (2017).
The participation to these funds is however unevenly distributed among the population; it is lower where it would be must necessary (young workers with law salaries).
Another major tend present in some countries has been to extend basic welfare provisions to all forms of work, including non standard contracts. But the level of these provisions is strictly conditioned by budget constraints: e.g. in Italy the employment benefits for non standard workers (so called collaborators) are of limited amount and duration.
8. Beyond insurance schemes: forms of minimum income
A major threat to the adequacy of pensions, and of other welfare sectors such as unemployment benefits, comes from the transformations of work indicated above, in particular from the diffusion of intermittent and precarious forms of employment.
The traditional system particularly of continental European states which has been built on the premise of stable careers and financed on contribution on wages, has become insufficient to guarantee adequate levels of pensions to a growing number of employees. This includes not only atypical workers but also employees afflicted by instability even through hired with standard contracts.
A set of measures aimed at remedying to the shortcoming of the traditional contributory system has been to “cover “ with fiscal support various periods of work inactivity, not only those due to reasons protected by law, such as work accidents illness, maternity leaves, periods of unemployment, but also to other personal reasons, such as education leaves.
But these partial corrections have proved insufficient to meet the needs of protection of many employees of the new economy; in particular those working part time, or with recurrent period of inactivity, or with low salaries.
The pressure has grown to depart from the traditional insurance scheme of pension based on actual work and on wage contributions and to move towards a universal system of welfare less dependent on work and more based on general fiscal support.
Some countries, not only the UK (which is influenced by the Beveridge tradition), but also the Netherlands have completely abandoned the contributory system and guaranteed to all citizen, regardless of their work career, some income support, often coupled with housing facilities and other services - for the old age and in case of inactivity (unvolontary).
A further evolution of most European welfare systems has been to add to the traditional forms of social protection, forms of minimum income directed to fight the various forms of poverty which have grown even in the rich areas of the continent and among the working population.
The national legislations have shaped differently the content of these measures: i.e. the level and duration of income support, the conditions of access and the type of conditionality.
The proposals to the introduce forms of “basic income” have been widely discussed, but not adopted a part from limited experiments. One obstacle is the cost of these proposals.
The adoption of a basic income in addition to the existing welfare provisions would involve an increase in social spending that would be difficult to sustain. On the other hand, its introduction instead of the other measures might well increase, rather than decrease, social inequalities, because well-off people are more capable than the poor of accessing the various social protection benefits.
The system introduced in Italy (Act 9/2018), in spite of the name “citizen income”, defines rather precisely the conditions of access to income support (i.e. the level of poverty linked to the family size and composition); the duration of the measure, which is presented as experimental (18 months), and the conditionalities. People able to work must be available for employment, and to this extent should sign a pact with the public employment services, committing themselves to accept jobs offered by the services.
The first application of the Act confirms the difficulty of implementing this measure, particularly in the areas of the country with few job opportunities and for workers with low level of education and obsolete skills (whose employability depend essentially on improving and adjourning their skills (the investments to this end remain insufficient also according to the Act).
9. Revitalisation of collective action
The changes in economic context and the diversification of work require a reappraisal not only of employment policies but also of collective bargaining and industrial relations.
Collective agreements have been shaped like statutory law, according to the dominant patterns of standard employment and mostly based on the experience of the social parties of industrialized countries. If they are to remain a major source of regulation and promotion of employment, they too must revise their objectives and practices so as to respond to the diversification of employment patterns, and on the other hand to the globalization of the markets.
Indeed these changes are affecting the system of Industrial Relations even more directly than the legal status of the contract of employment, in so far as industrial relations are exposed, often without any protection, to the pressures of the markets, and because the diversification of work affects the very basis of collective action of the workers, more than the initiatives of the employers.
- These factors have altered the power relations among the social parties to the detriment of the labor unions and account for the growing difficulties of traditional Industrial Relations which are visible even in the strongest systems of central and Northern Europe.
However here too the responses of the various national systems are not uniform as it is shown by the main indicators, in particular by the variation of union density.
Union density has been declining in most European countries. This is seen as a clear sign of the crisis of the systems of industrial relations which have in the Unions the main protagonist. But still major differences persist the various among countries.
Moreover the decline of average union density and the even more pronounced decline of industrial conflict (which has been confined to the public sector) are not fully reflected in the coverage of collective bargaining. Here the variations among countries are different from those of Union density due to the impact of other factors, in particular of legislation and of public policies concerning industrial relations.
The coverage of national collective agreements has continued to be relatively high also in countries where the rate of unionization has been traditionally low such as France and Spain and has further declined in recent years. This is due mainly to State legislations which have supported the application of national and multi employer collective agreements beyond the area of unions influence by way of various mechanism of legal extension of these agreements to all the firms and employees of the various economic sectors.
This promotional legislation has not been changed, and indeed has been reinforced in some countries like Germany: while in the past the extension could be decided on the condition that the agreement covered the majority of the interested firms and employees, recent legislation has lifted this condition in order to facilitate the extension. It has provided that the extension can be ordered at request of the bargaining parties following a discretionary evaluation of the public authorities.
Moreover legal minimum wages have been introduced in Germany, one of the few countries of Europe, together with Italy, where they did not exist as a way to sustain the salaries of occasional and precarious types of work, so called mini jobs, which are much lower than the average.
Even in the countries like Italy where a legal system of extension does not exist, other forms of indirect support of the effects of the agreements are in place. Courts decisions and administrative provisions require the respect of the standards fixed by national agreements as a condition to receive various fiscal benefits. The same wage standards are relevant to determine the basis for social security contributions.
The role and effectiveness of collective agreements have been indirectly sustained also by the law which recognizes the right to bargain only to representative unions, in order to oppose the fragmentation and hence the weakening of the bargaining parties.
These legal interventions have been important in supporting collective agreements; even though it is doubtful that they may be sufficient to redress the balance of power which is still unfavourable for the unions.
Another form of promotional legislation has been adopted by some countries, and endorsed by an EU directive, which grants consultation and participation rights to workers representatives on major enterprise decisions affecting working conditions. The experience of countries – Germany in the first place - where this participation is widely adopted has shown positive results not only in facilitating employment relations, but also in improving both the welfare of workers and the productivity of firms.
- The Italian legislator has never applied the EU directive intervened and has avoided to introduce forms of unions participation in the governance of enterprises.
- But recently the law has granted fiscal incentives to collective agreements which introduce wages linked to productivity and supplementary forms of welfare. In addition it has increased these incentives if the parties agree to introduce forms of joint participation aimed to joint administering those chapters of the agreements.
- This kind of indirect support to participation has proved very effective, because the number of company and local agreements has increased greatly in the last years (over 40.000 recorded by the Ministery of Labor).
10. The challenge of decentralization
- The transformation of work and of the markets have exerted strong pressure to decentralize the structure of collective bargaining which in quite a few European countries was rather centralized, as reflected in the central position of national sectorial agreements.
- Decentralized bargaining, mainly to the company and plant level, has acquired a decisive role in most countries even where the national and multiemployer agreements were traditionally prevalent.
- The national legislators have encouraged this process of decentralization on various conditions and with a different impact on the role of national agreements. Some legislations (Spain) have completly altered the traditional hierarchy of the bargaining structure by attributing to company agreements the primary role in regulating most labor issues, including the possibility to fix conditions of work less favorable to employees than those set nationally.
A more nuanced solution has been adopted in France where the law has attributed to decentralized agreements priority in the regulation of some issues not reserved to national agreements; but it has provided the duty of the employers to bargain periodically over most labor matters.
Similar measures have been decided, although less clearly, by Italian law, which has recognized to decentralized agreements, contrary to tradition, the same legal status and effectiveness as the national agreements.
- Also the reactions of the social parties to the decentralization of collective bargaining are different in the various industrial relations systems. In countries like Germany and Italy the central labor unions have been able to control the process of decentralization, at least in the strong economic sectors and in medium large firms. The possibility to derogate from the national standards has been scarcely used, mainly in cases of serious economic crisis, in order to prevent mass dismissals and plant closures.
In others member states (like Spain) the decentralization has altered more profoundly the structure of bargaining, with negative effects on its governance. The highly decentralized structure of bargaining which has always been common in the UK is considered to be a major factor of weakness of industrial relations.
11. The role of the state and unions policies
An important variable for the future of Industrial Relations is the role of the States, because particularly in Europe public policies have always been influencial in shaping the institutional context in which the parties operate. State interventions have been mostly supportive to labor Unions, even though in different degrees which have contributed to shape the “variety of capitalism”. But in recent years this prolabor attitude has been changing under the influence of liberistic ideologies and of the pressure of markets.
In some countries restrictive economic practices and legislation, as shown above, have contributed to reduce the union influence. In others, like Italy, public policies have been ambivalent and variable according to the political orientation of governments.
The future public choices in this respect will be decisive. We are convinced that the adverse factors which are weakening collective bargaining can be opposed only by concurrent action and interplay by public institutions and social actors.
A major challenge for public policy is to redress the balance of power which globalization and the crisis have made unfavorable for the labor side and the unions.
Public support for collective action at present has some specific testing grounds: a) recognition of basic individual and collective rights, beginning with freedom of association and of collective action; b) recognition and support of workers participation in the organization of work and in enterprise life; c) promotion of the right of employees representatives to participate in the public institutions which provide employment and welfare services; d) provision of a universal safety net to the collective participation of employees and citizens in local institutions which are still decisive even in time of globalization.
Whatever the state policies the future of Industrial relations will depend on the capacity of the labor movement to find new reasons and objectives for a common action.
The growth and influence of the European unions have been built, differently from the trend prevailing in the USA, not only on collective bargaining, but on a vast spectrum of social and political actions, including the participation within the enterprises and in public institutions in charge of labor policies, training and welfare policies.
The value of this multiplicity of arenas in face of the present global transformations, has been confirmed by most European unions, even though their relations with the traditional labor parties has been loosened, and the declining fortunes of labor friendly governments have often reduced their financial and institutional support to unions activities.
On the other hand many European unions are experimenting innovative strategies of organization. The decline of membership and the increasingly difficult relationship with the State have persuaded many European unions to experiment innovative forms of recruiting activities similar to those practiced by American unions, in particular towards the new types of employees, skilled and unskilled, which populate the present labor markets.
But these practices of union-revitalization have met with uneven degree of success, due to the difficulty to overcome the obstacles which contrast collective action and organization.
The Italian unions have also directed specific sectors of their organization to operate among the new non standard workers, here too with mixed results.
Forms of collaboration and alliance with other types of social movements have been searched; but in most cases have remained at an initial stage, due to the difficulty to find common objectives with the traditional goals and often to the resistance of the unions leadership.
In fact greater attention has been given by the unions of the major countries to service activities of different kinds (social assistance, training services) which have proved useful
not only to increase the allegiance of members and the attractiveness of membership, but also to compensate for the reduced amount of member dues and of public resources.
12. Concluding remarks
In conclusion we want to make a general point: the transformations of work which we have discussed live have not only the specific implications on the various areas of labor law and industrial relations. They ---- us to redefine the very forms of labor law and social policies.
These policies should not be concerned exclusively with protection of workers and even distribution of income, assuming, as in the past, that growth was a self- sustaining mechanism, in a linear direction of development. Labor and social policies, and ourselves as socially commited scholars, must share the concern for the conditions and for the sustainability of growth.
This line of argument has indeed --- implications: namely that the specific instruments of our discipline need not be confined to reacting to the negative effects on labor of the existing economic policies but finalize them (together with other policies) to change those patterns for a more inclusive and sustainable growth.
A second implication is that the economic performance should be evaluated not only according to material parameters, even less to short term financial accumulation, but including social and welfare indicators.
Some of these indicators have been elaborated by various international and research organizations, but still are not taken seriously by policy makers.
A similar approach has been adopted eg.in the European Lisbon Treaty (art.9), which States that all major economic decisions, at national and international level, should take into account their impact on social and individual welfare. It is an important policy approach whose implementation is meeting many obstacles in the actual national and European policymaking.
Compila il seguente form. Ti risponderemo il prima possibile!