Tiziano Treu Official Site logo Home Biografia Articoli Guida Lavoro Interviste Libri Notizie Foto & Video Contatti
Tecnologie

Montreal

Montreal

The paper discusses the impact of the new technologies on the legal categories and the regulation of work.

1. Content of the paper


In this presentation  we will select (concentrate)  four mains areas  where the transformations of work  have a major impact on labor law and labor policies:


-   The regulations of  the new  non standard types of employment.


-   The relevance  of the  diversification of work  for social security.


-   The regulation of workers mobility  in the labor market.


-   The role of industrial relations in the  new (digital) economy.



2. A general introduction


Labor law and Industrial Relations  are challenged  by the great transformation of the present  economy  and society.


The impact of these  transformations  is controversial. Some analyses predict  radical changes not only  in the quantity and quality  of future  employment,  but in  the very essence  of our discipline: namely  a universal  neoliberal  transformations of industrial relations and an  irreversible decline  of the legal  and collective regulation of  employment.


Comparative  research  gives some evidence  that the  impact  is not predetermined, but is  influenced by the existing  institutions and by  the political decisions adopted in different  times and in various countries.


Indeed  the reactions of the  various national  systems of I will concentrate on the European experience) and  the measures implemented by them to react to this  critical  scenario have been  different; and the differences seen  to be on the increase, contrary  to the assumption of a gradual  convergence   among  the national  systems.


An open alternative concerns the content  of these  measures: are they  specific  adoptations of the traditional  legal system  sufficient  to restore  this role  and efficientiveness, or is it necessary a radical  change  of “paradigm”. In fact  most European  examples  seen to be  of the former type.  


The European approach  is a  significant  testing ground for detecting the reactions  of labor law and industrial relations  to the transformations of the world of work. The analysis of these reactions may also offer some  arguments to test verify the opinions  mentioned above which envisage an inevitable decline of Industrial Relations.


The various European  states have different  social  and legal traditions,  but the European Union  has contributed to spread common practices  and rules in the field of employment and industrial relations, which have  built a common social dimension, usually named  “social model”.


Relative to most other  areas of the world this 'model' is characterized by high  standards in the major aspects of labor regulations: guarantees of collective and individual  social rights, statutory  legal and collective regulations.


In spite  of its achivements,  the established system of social rights and policies has not fully protected  the European workers and citizens from the damages of the recent economic crisis.



3.    The impact of  new technologies  on the legal categories


The paper will  discuss here  some of the  major challenges which  the tranformations  of the  world of work are  posing to labor  law and social policies.


 A major challenge comes from the impact of the new technologies, in particular  digital, on the quantity and quality of  work.


Forecast  that most traditional jobs will disappear in the near future are probably exaggerated. Yet the impact is bound to grow.


In any case  the effects of  digital  innovations on employment are bound to grow, especially in traditional repetitive jobs.


It is significant that, in Europe, the threat from the digital revolution has re-opened the debate not only on flexible working hours, but also on their reduction. The recently renegotiated contract of German metalworkers entitles them to reduce (for two years) their weekly working hours to 28 (with a partial reduction in salary) or, if they prefer, to return to a normal working week of 35 hours. In return, the employers are permitted to exercise greater flexibility in organizing working time. Part-time working (not always voluntary) is on the increase, emerging as a widespread system of work-sharing, often within the family.


The forms  and quality  of work will certainly be affected by unprecedetecd  change leading   particularly where repetitive work is concerned, leading to the polarization of jobs. The change is so profound that the inadequacy not only of traditional regulations but even of the categories on which labour law are based is becoming evident, first and foremost subordinate employment.


The various forms  of platform  - based  employment  are an  extreme example of the insufficience of the traditional  categories  of labor contracts.


It is significant that  the regulation of these forms  has  proved quite  controversial and  have  received different  responses  by national  legislators,  by judges and even  by social  parties. Some responses  are inclined to include gig economy  workers. In the  category  of the subordinate  workers  and recognize them  the  associated  rights. Other emplasize  their  indipendent status. Some  legislatory have  created  intermediate  categories  of employment contracts under various  names: parasubordinated jobs (Italy), economically dependent employment (Spain), relations similar to subordinate employment (Germany), workers (UK).  


To these contracts are applied some, but not all, of the traditional protections afforded to subordinate employees: in particular, minimum wages, safety standards, social security, accident insurance, etc.  But the creation of these new categories has not clarified the borderlines between them; on the contrary, it has  sometimes made them difficult to identify.


I am  convinced  that in order to provide  an adequate response,   more  attention should be  paid  to the needs  of protection  and of support  of these   new workers,  instead  of relying on  traditional  legal categories.



4. From  legal  categories to the modulation of protections


 Such an approach  is followed  by the  French  legislator  (Act August, 8, 2016, n. 1088)  which has  recognized  to these  workers   a number of  essential rights and protections: protection  against work accidents, right to  association, adequate training, etc. Not claiming to provide legal definitions of digital employment  the law has  abandoned  the all-or-nothing logic inherent in the rigid traditional categories.


A recent Italian  Act (101/2019)  follows a similar  approach. It adopts  a rather loose definition  of platform  workers, avoiding  precise  legal  qualification, which  is left  to labor  courts. On the  other Land it  introduces  a minimal  regulation   granting  some rights  to those workers  who  deliver  goods (so called riders):  insurance against  work accidents and  illness,  the same protective  norms  on health  and safety  which are applicable  to all workers; right to  payments linked  to actual delivery  of the  good (but not totally). Collective  agreements may  provide forms  of payment  linked to  the way in which the activity is  performed.



Moreover  the law gives  to collective bargaining the power to redefine and clarify the borders between different forms of atypical  coordinates employment, while adapting the treatment to the specific requirements of individual types of work and business (Leg. Decree 81/2015, Article 2.2).  


Equally significant  of this approach is  the ruling  of the  European  Commission. While  mentioning  the possible  use of subordinate employment criteria for settling so-called “platform workers” cases and disputes, the Commission merely invites member States to ensure that workers benefit from “fair working conditions” and “adequate and sustainable social protection”, identified by considering “the different needs and the innovative nature of collaborative business models”.


In any case  the variable  character of the new jobs  suggests that rigid legal  interventions  are less effective  that  flexible  regulations  which  can be better  determined by collective agreements.


The diversification  of the  forms of work  and their  difference  from the standard   employment  have  led some  authors  to elaborate  the notion  of “ personal  work relationship” and to consider  it central  to labor law,  in lieu  of the “employment  contract”. This doctrine  justly  argues for the need  to extend  the application  of some  rights  and protections  beyond  the  borders  of traditional employment to the  diversified  universe of the  new forms  of work.  


But this  argument  should  not be pushed  to the point of diluting  all the  body  of labor  law into a generic  and undistinct regulation  valid  for any type of human activity.  


The real challenge for our  discipline  is to analyse and interpret the specific  traits of the new works and the needs of the people who  perform them  in order  to distinguish those parts of  traditional labor law which are applicable  to then, from these norms  and policies  which  are irrelevant  on even  counter  productive. Some traditional protections may loose importance  for employees  who  have acquired great  operational  indipendence, even  though they are hired  under  an employment  contract. The some  is true  for people  who work  on a digital  environment  where   the  traditional  limits of space and time are being blurred.


The selection of appropriate  regulation  is decisive  and not  easy  to decide.  This regulation  should be  indentified  by matching  the function of the  different  norms with  the needs of protection  and of promotion  of the  people  working  in different environments,  taking  into account  of the  reason  of  business  and the objective of sustainable  growth.  


A similar  principle  is asserted in the European  guidelines  quoted  above.


This is  a general  principle which should be tested  on the  ground  according  to the  specific  work  and business  context;  with  the caveat  of avoiding  both  excessive   rigidity  for business and lack  of protection for the employees.  Such  an approach  might favour  a regulatory  approach  not only  better  finalized but also  more flexible  and simplified.  It might also  reduce  the legal  norms of detail  and increase the importance  of minimum  standards,  national  and in  perspective  supranational,   as advocated by  the “Decent  Work Agenda” of the ILO.



5. Procedures instead of rigid rules: working time and job classifications


In some areas substantive  norms  might prove impraticable  and  be better  substituted by procedural  regulations. Two good exemple are the regulation of  working time  and of job qualification.


In both areas the new  technologies,  in particular  digital,   have altered  the material  basis on  which traditional  norms have  been built: on one side  the organization  and the very notion of “time  and space  of work”; on the other  the relations between  human skills and intelligent  machines.


In the former area the recent  Italian  legislation  on the so called  “smart working”  (Act 81) is significant  because  it has abandoned   the traditional     approach  to the regulation of working  time  and has  left  to the  individual  agreement between  the employer and  the worker  the  role of regulating  the distribution of work  time and  of setting the best  worklife balance (with in the  maximum  limits of total  hours fixed  by European  directives).


 The assumption  is that this solution would favor  both the need  of business flexibility  and a good conciliation  between  work time  and  personal needs of the employees.


While acknowleding the importance of the  objective pursued by the Act, the decision  to give a decisive role  to the individual  contract  has raised quite a few objections. The fact of working in a digital  environment  does not  increase  the capacity  of the individual  employer  to determine the conditions of work  including a acritical aspect such as working timer  with real autonomy  vis à vis  the employer.  


More  balanced  and equitable  solutions  might come  from some  French and Italian   experiences  where  collective agreements  (mainly companywide). Instead of setting fixed rules of working time have  offered  to the  parties a set of options (a menu)  of different time  schedules  in which   the individuals employees  and employers can choose  according  to the  circumstances and needs.


 In the second  area Act 81/2015 has changed  the traditional  rule  which limited the possibility to change the jobs assigned by contract  to the  employee only to job positions having  equivalent  skill  content and  value (the notion  of equivalence being strictly interpreted by courts).


The Act,  acknowleding  the difficulty to regulate  by law the variable content of the present jobs and skills, has  assigned  to collective agreements the task to determine the rules, mainly  the procedures, necessary  to govern  labor mobility within the firms,  while safeguarding  or  developing  the professional skills of the employees.


In both cases collective  agreements are challenged to go beyond the traditional  forms of rigid regulation  similar to those of the law and to adopt procedural  solution with a “problem solving” approach.


This new  task  can be adequately performed  only if industrial relations are  capable  of interpreting  the present  realities of work  and are  supported  in their functioning  by the common will  of the parties and by public policies (which is not always the case).


6. The European  policies of flexicurity


Labor law has  always been  concerned   with regulating  the conditions  of work not only in the individual  employment relations  but also  in the labor market.


The latter function   has acquired  growing importance  in recent years, due to the  increased  dynamism  of labor markets and consequent greater  need of  mobility  for both workers  and enterprises. This trend  has raised (or made more acute)  a general policy  problem: namely  how to  facilitate mobility  on the labor  market  without depriving  employees  of the necessary  protection in employment.


European  directives have tradionally  recognized  that  the need of flexibility  in work has to be balanced by measures to guarantee protection  and assistance to workers in the labor market.


This policy which  goes under the heading  of flexicurity  has been  officially  adopted by most member states  but has been  implemented  with  different and uneven result in various countries


The essential  test  of effectiveness depends on the balance maintained between the two terms of the trade off, flexibility  and security. This balance  has been  uneven. It has  been better maintained in some countries (central - Northern Europe) well equipped with active labor policies and with strong welfare systems. Lacking these conditions, the balance has been precarious and the measures aimed at workers security have not always protected them from the risks of unemployment.


The economic crisis of the last decade has increased the difficulty to keep this balance, particularly to protect and assist the displaced workers  for the time necessary for their reinstatement. The traditional  income support  provided by state agencies to workers unemployed or suspended   from work  due to  enterprise crises, has become  often insufficient  to cover the periods of inactivity  of these workers.


For this reason the European Parliament has proposed  a reframing of the policy of flexicurity.


Some countries,  beginning  with Italy, have  prolonged the duration  of welfare support to workers  suspended from work, but at high costs for public finance  and with the risk of “freezing” too many employees in firms and  jobs doomed to extinction  and of substracting  resources  to investments and job creation.


 Alternative  policies are being experimented  to provide  better placement  and replacement  services finalized to support  firms and  employees  in the periods of transition  which  are becoming  a recurrent or normal  feature of modern labor market.


The Italian  legislator  (Act -----) has decided  a robust intervention  aimed at strengthening these services,  with considerable investments  in their organization, informatic structures and   skilled personnel. The priority  of these  measures is reserved  to people in conditions of poverty which benefit from  a basic income  recently implemented, so called “citizen income” (see below).


This priority  should  not go  to the  detriment  of two other groups in need of these services: one  unemployed  workers, particularly when unemployment is  of long duration (a large percentage of the total); two, those in transition  from different jobs  who  need intensive retraining.


The role  of public  authorities, national and mostly regional,  is still  decisive,  even though  authorized  private agencies are now called to collaborate, particularly to provide  special personal services.



The economic crisis has   shown  the limits of the traditional policy of flexicurity and has required a new approach  also by  firms  and their  management. The European Council  in the document mentioned above (“The second phase of flexicurity”) has recommended  to promote  measures of internal  flexibility  with  the aim of minimizing the  risk of numerical  flexibility,  i.e. of personnel reduction.


These measures  should be specified by the employer in  HR provisional  programs, including  in particular training and retraining, targeted to the employees most exposed to technological  obsolescence; and promotion internal labor  mobility  and organizational innovations aimed  to maximize the employability of the employees. Another  measure frequently  adopted, also in Italy has been  to grant to employers a wide discretion to introduce flexible working time and to change job assignments to their employees. This increased  flexibility  has been  often  accompanied by the duty, fixed  by law or by collective agreements, to retrain the employees to the new posts.


This form of functional flexibility, particularly when introduced in agreement with workers representatives, has proved useful in  reducing the recourse to alternative measures of external flexibility such as outsourcing and use of temporary fixed term contracts.



7. The challenges to social security


 The welfare systems built  in the last Century, which  are a fundamental component  of the European social  model, are under  stress,  due to  adverse  convergent  factors. On the one hand  financial constraints are  reducing  the available  resources, on the other  the rapidly  aging  population (faster than  anticipated)  demands  more resources  both for pensions and health care. Moreover  the low birth rate in countries  like Italy threatens to dry up  the sources for financing the welfare system. The old age dependency ratio (percentage of active population on the total) is already at 55% and is excepted to rise.


A reaction  common to most  countries  has been to  postpone the age of retirement, but with  different speed  and  various  exceptions in the various systems.


In particular exceptions are provided, in Italy like elsewhere, for people  with various kind of disadvantages: workers  who have started  early their employment (in Italy, 18/19 years); employed in heavy and dangerous activities, people affected by serious invalidity; women with children.


A recent  Italian Act (4/2019) has  introduced  a general reduction  of retirement  age  (down from 67 to 62 ) which has been  criticized for further  increasing the already heavy burden of pensions on the state budget and for  shifting  uncreasing  costs on the future generations.


A second policy  recommended  by the European Union  is promote measures  of active ageing, within the enterprises as a necessary  complement to raising  the retirement age.


The employers have  the main  responsibility  for introducing  various  measures  age friendly:  eg.  for adopting flexible  forms of  worktime, reducing work loads, refraiming career paths; targeting  specific  forms of training  and reskilling.


Some  of these  initiatives  of the  enterprise are encouraged by state policies, which have  introduced  different  kinds of support, eg.  for the retraining  of aging  employees, for promoting  forms of  gradual retirement and exchange  of  expertise  between  young  and old  employees.


 The major emphasis of public  interventions  has been  to guarantee the financial  sustainability of the welfare  systems, in particular of  pensions and this has gone often to the  detriment of the  adequacy  of the measures to meet the (growing) needs of the  beneficiaries.


A policy common  to most European  countries for sustaining  the adequacy of pensions has been  to support  with public  incentives various forms of supplementary pensions, in order to build a second pillar of the system. In Italy pension funds  set up  by collective  agreements cover 7.9 million  employees in the private sector (2017); funds providing health care supplementary to the  public system cover 10.6 million employees (2017).


The participation to these  funds is  however  unevenly distributed among the population;  it is lower  where it would be must  necessary (young workers with law salaries).


Another  major tend present in some  countries  has been   to extend basic  welfare  provisions  to all forms  of work, including  non standard contracts. But  the level of these  provisions is strictly conditioned by budget constraints:  e.g. in  Italy  the employment  benefits for  non  standard workers (so called  collaborators) are of  limited  amount and duration.  





8. Beyond insurance  schemes: forms of minimum  income


A major  threat to  the adequacy  of pensions, and of other welfare sectors such as unemployment benefits, comes from the transformations of work  indicated above,  in particular  from the diffusion  of intermittent and precarious  forms of employment.


The traditional system  particularly  of continental  European states which  has been built on the premise of  stable careers and financed on contribution on wages, has become  insufficient  to guarantee  adequate  levels of pensions  to a  growing  number  of employees. This includes  not  only  atypical workers  but also  employees afflicted  by instability even through hired with  standard  contracts.


 A set of measures  aimed at  remedying to the  shortcoming  of the traditional  contributory system  has been  to “cover “ with fiscal  support various  periods of  work inactivity, not only   those due to  reasons  protected by law, such  as  work accidents illness, maternity leaves,  periods of unemployment, but  also to other  personal reasons,  such as  education leaves.


 But these  partial  corrections  have proved  insufficient to meet the needs of protection of many  employees  of the new economy; in particular those  working part time,  or with recurrent period of inactivity, or with  low salaries.


The pressure  has grown to depart  from the traditional  insurance scheme  of pension based on actual  work and on wage contributions and to move towards  a universal  system of welfare less dependent  on work  and more based on general fiscal support.


Some countries, not only  the UK (which is influenced by the Beveridge tradition), but also  the Netherlands have  completely  abandoned the contributory  system and guaranteed  to all citizen, regardless of their work career, some income  support, often  coupled with  housing facilities  and other services -  for the old age  and  in case of inactivity (unvolontary).


A further  evolution of most European  welfare systems  has been to  add to the traditional  forms of social  protection,  forms of minimum  income  directed to fight the various  forms of poverty   which have  grown even  in the rich  areas  of the  continent and  among the working population.


 The national  legislations  have  shaped differently  the  content of these  measures: i.e. the level  and  duration of income  support,  the conditions of  access and the  type of conditionality.


The proposals to the introduce  forms of “basic  income”  have been widely discussed, but not adopted  a part from  limited experiments. One obstacle  is the cost of these proposals.


 The adoption of a basic income in addition to the existing welfare provisions would involve an increase in social spending that would be difficult to sustain. On the other hand, its introduction instead of the other measures might well increase, rather than decrease, social inequalities, because well-off people are more capable than the poor of accessing the various social protection benefits.


The system introduced in Italy (Act 9/2018), in spite of the  name “citizen income”, defines  rather precisely the conditions of access  to income  support (i.e. the  level of poverty linked to the family size  and composition); the duration  of the measure, which is presented as experimental (18 months),  and the  conditionalities.  People  able to work must  be available  for employment, and to  this extent  should sign a pact with the public  employment  services, committing  themselves to  accept jobs offered by the services.


The first application  of the  Act  confirms  the difficulty  of implementing  this  measure, particularly  in the areas  of the country   with few job  opportunities and for  workers with  low level  of education and obsolete skills (whose employability  depend  essentially  on improving  and adjourning their skills  (the investments  to this end  remain  insufficient  also according to the Act).


9.  Revitalisation  of collective  action


 The changes  in economic context  and the diversification of work require a reappraisal not only of employment policies but also of collective bargaining and industrial relations.


 Collective agreements have  been  shaped  like statutory law,  according to the dominant  patterns of standard employment and mostly  based  on the experience  of the social  parties of industrialized countries. If they  are to remain  a major source  of regulation  and promotion  of employment, they too must revise their objectives and practices so as to respond  to the diversification  of employment patterns, and on the other hand to the globalization of the markets.


Indeed  these  changes  are affecting the system of  Industrial Relations even more  directly than  the legal  status of the contract of employment, in so far  as  industrial relations are exposed, often without any  protection, to the pressures  of the  markets,  and because  the diversification  of work  affects the very  basis   of collective  action of the workers,  more than  the initiatives of the employers.


-   These factors  have  altered   the power  relations  among  the  social  parties to the  detriment of the labor  unions and account  for the growing  difficulties  of traditional  Industrial Relations  which are  visible  even in the  strongest systems of central and Northern  Europe.


However  here too the responses of the various national systems are not uniform  as it is shown by the main indicators, in particular by  the variation of union density.


Union  density  has been  declining  in most  European  countries. This is seen as a clear sign  of the crisis  of the systems of industrial relations  which  have in the  Unions  the main protagonist. But still major  differences persist the various among countries.


Moreover the decline of average  union density and the even more  pronounced  decline of industrial conflict (which has been  confined to the public sector) are not fully reflected in the coverage of collective bargaining. Here the variations among countries are  different from those of Union density due to the impact of other factors, in particular of  legislation and of public policies concerning industrial relations.


The coverage of national collective agreements has continued  to be relatively high  also in countries where the rate of unionization has been traditionally low  such as France and Spain and has further declined in recent years. This is due mainly to State  legislations which  have supported the application of national and multi employer  collective agreements beyond the  area of unions influence by way of various mechanism of  legal extension of these agreements to all the  firms and employees  of the various economic sectors.


This promotional legislation has not been changed, and  indeed has been reinforced in some countries like Germany: while in the past the extension could be  decided  on the condition that the agreement  covered the majority  of the interested firms and employees, recent legislation has lifted this condition in order  to facilitate the extension. It has provided that the extension can be ordered  at request  of the bargaining parties following a discretionary  evaluation of the public authorities.


Moreover legal minimum wages have been  introduced in  Germany, one of the few countries of Europe, together with Italy, where they did not exist  as a way to sustain the salaries of  occasional and precarious  types of work, so called mini jobs, which are much lower than the average.


Even in the countries like Italy  where a legal system of extension does not exist,  other forms of indirect support  of the effects of the agreements  are in place. Courts decisions and administrative provisions require  the respect of  the standards fixed by national agreements as a condition to  receive various fiscal  benefits. The same wage standards are relevant to  determine the basis for social security contributions.


The role and  effectiveness of collective  agreements  have been indirectly sustained  also by  the law  which recognizes the right to bargain  only to representative unions, in order to oppose the fragmentation  and hence the weakening  of the bargaining parties.


These legal  interventions have been  important  in supporting  collective  agreements;  even though it is doubtful that they may be sufficient to redress the balance  of power which is still  unfavourable for the  unions.


Another form of promotional  legislation  has been adopted  by some countries, and endorsed by an EU  directive, which  grants consultation and participation  rights to workers  representatives on major  enterprise decisions affecting working conditions. The experience  of countries – Germany in the first place - where this participation is widely adopted has shown positive results not only in facilitating employment relations, but also in improving both  the welfare of workers  and the productivity of firms.



-   The Italian legislator has  never  applied  the EU  directive intervened and has  avoided  to introduce  forms  of unions participation  in the governance of enterprises.


-   But recently the law has granted   fiscal incentives to collective  agreements  which  introduce  wages linked to productivity  and supplementary forms of welfare. In addition  it has increased  these  incentives  if the parties agree to introduce forms of joint participation aimed  to joint  administering   those chapters  of the agreements.


-   This kind of indirect  support  to participation  has  proved very  effective,  because  the number of company and local agreements has increased  greatly  in the last  years (over 40.000 recorded by the Ministery of Labor).



10. The challenge of decentralization


-   The transformation  of work and of the markets have  exerted  strong pressure to decentralize the structure of collective bargaining which in  quite a few European countries was rather centralized, as reflected in the central position of national sectorial  agreements.


-   Decentralized  bargaining, mainly to the company and plant level, has  acquired a  decisive role in most countries  even where  the national and multiemployer agreements were traditionally prevalent.


-   The national legislators have encouraged this process of decentralization on various conditions and  with a different impact on the role of national agreements. Some legislations (Spain) have  completly altered the traditional hierarchy of  the bargaining structure by attributing to company agreements  the primary  role in regulating most labor issues, including the possibility to fix conditions of work less favorable to employees than those set nationally.


A more nuanced solution has been adopted  in France where the law has attributed to  decentralized agreements priority in the regulation of some issues not reserved to national agreements; but it  has provided the duty of the employers to bargain periodically over most labor matters.


Similar measures have been decided, although less clearly, by Italian law, which has recognized to decentralized agreements, contrary to tradition, the  same legal  status and effectiveness as the  national agreements.


-   Also the reactions of the social parties to the decentralization  of collective  bargaining  are different in the various  industrial relations systems. In countries like Germany and Italy the central labor unions have been able  to control the process of decentralization, at least in the strong economic sectors and in medium  large firms. The  possibility to derogate from the national standards has been  scarcely used, mainly in cases of serious economic crisis, in order  to prevent mass dismissals and plant closures.



In others member states (like Spain)  the decentralization  has altered  more profoundly the structure  of bargaining, with negative  effects on its governance. The highly  decentralized structure of bargaining  which has always been common in the UK is considered  to be a major  factor  of weakness  of industrial relations.



11. The role  of the state and unions policies


An important  variable for the future of Industrial Relations  is the role of the States, because particularly  in Europe  public policies  have always been influencial in shaping the institutional context in which the parties operate. State interventions have  been  mostly  supportive to labor Unions, even  though in different degrees which have contributed to shape  the “variety of capitalism”. But in recent  years this prolabor attitude has been changing under the influence of liberistic ideologies  and of  the pressure of markets.


In some countries  restrictive  economic practices and legislation, as shown  above, have  contributed  to reduce the union influence. In others, like Italy, public policies  have  been  ambivalent  and  variable  according to the  political orientation of governments.


The future public choices in this respect  will be decisive. We are  convinced  that  the adverse factors  which are  weakening collective bargaining  can be  opposed  only by concurrent  action and interplay by public  institutions and social actors.


A major challenge for public policy is to redress the balance of power which globalization and the crisis have made unfavorable for the labor side and the unions.


Public support for collective action at present has some  specific testing grounds: a) recognition of  basic individual and collective rights, beginning with freedom of association and  of collective action; b) recognition and support of workers participation in the organization of work and in enterprise life; c) promotion of the right of employees representatives  to participate in the public institutions  which provide employment and welfare services; d) provision of a universal safety net to the collective participation of employees and citizens in local institutions which are still  decisive even in time of globalization.


Whatever the state policies the future  of Industrial  relations  will depend on the capacity  of the labor movement to find new reasons  and objectives  for a  common action.


The growth and influence  of  the European  unions  have been built,  differently  from  the trend prevailing in the USA, not only on collective  bargaining,  but  on a vast  spectrum of  social and political actions, including the participation  within the enterprises  and in public  institutions  in charge  of labor policies, training and  welfare policies.


The value  of this  multiplicity  of arenas in face of  the present global transformations, has been  confirmed  by most  European unions, even  though  their relations  with the traditional  labor parties  has been  loosened, and the  declining  fortunes of  labor friendly governments have  often reduced their  financial and  institutional support to unions activities.


On the other hand many European unions are  experimenting innovative strategies of organization. The decline of membership  and the  increasingly  difficult  relationship  with the State  have persuaded  many European unions to experiment  innovative  forms of recruiting activities  similar to those  practiced by American  unions, in particular  towards  the new types of employees, skilled  and unskilled, which  populate the present  labor markets.


But these  practices of union-revitalization have  met with  uneven  degree  of success, due to the difficulty  to overcome  the obstacles  which  contrast  collective action and organization.


The Italian unions have also  directed specific  sectors of their  organization to  operate among  the new non  standard workers, here too with mixed results.


Forms of collaboration and alliance  with  other  types  of social  movements  have  been  searched; but  in most cases  have  remained  at an initial  stage, due to  the  difficulty   to find  common objectives with the traditional  goals and often  to the  resistance  of the unions leadership.


In fact  greater  attention has been given by the unions of the major  countries to service  activities  of different kinds (social assistance, training services) which have proved  useful  


not only to increase  the allegiance of members  and the attractiveness of membership,  but also to compensate for the reduced amount  of member dues and of public resources.



12. Concluding remarks


In conclusion  we want to make  a general point: the transformations of work which we have  discussed live  have not only  the specific  implications on the various areas  of labor  law and  industrial  relations. They ---- us  to redefine the very forms of labor law and social policies.


These policies should  not be concerned  exclusively with protection of workers  and even distribution of income, assuming, as in the past, that growth was  a self- sustaining mechanism, in a linear  direction  of development. Labor and social  policies, and ourselves  as socially  commited scholars,  must share the concern for the conditions and for the sustainability of growth.



This line of argument has indeed  --- implications: namely that the specific  instruments of our  discipline need not be confined  to reacting  to the negative effects on labor  of the  existing economic policies  but  finalize them (together with other policies) to change those  patterns for a more  inclusive  and sustainable growth.


A second implication  is that  the economic performance should be evaluated not only according to material parameters, even less to short term financial accumulation, but including social and welfare indicators.


Some of these indicators have been elaborated by various international and research organizations,   but still are not taken seriously by policy makers.  


A similar approach has been  adopted eg.in the European Lisbon Treaty (art.9), which States that all major economic decisions, at national and international level, should take into account their impact on social and individual welfare. It is an  important  policy  approach  whose implementation  is meeting  many  obstacles  in the actual  national  and European  policymaking.












Vuoi saperene di più?

Compila il seguente form. Ti risponderemo il prima possibile!

Privacy: