Tiziano Treu Official Site logo Home Biografia Articoli Guida Lavoro Interviste Libri Notizie Foto & Video Contatti
Sostenibilità

Presentation of Valentina Cagnin’s book.

Presentation of Valentina Cagnin’s book.

In this presentation of Valentina Cagnin's book, Tiziano Treu discusses the potential of Sustainable Development as a guiding criterion for future labor law. He explores two possible implications of this approach: a strategic and a methodological one.

This book deals with two fundamental matters that go beyond the Italian debate: the issue of the crisis of labour law and that of new possible perspectives of development inspired by the Sustainability paradigm. The ambitious objective of the essay is to compare theoretical hypotheses, normative tendencies and practices present in the International and Italian scenario, in order to verify if Sustainable Development can be relevant as a guiding criterion for the future labour law, that is “to be useful in order to guide the exit from the crisis and, at the same time, to define the founding values ​​of a new sustainable labour law "(p. 14).

The author is aware of the complexity of the issues involved and deals with them with great care, almost cautiously, avoiding both emphatic proclamations and easy generalizations, both of which are not infrequent in dealing with these issues. Rather than definitive solutions, arguments are explained with the aim of providing the reader with a reasoning basis to verify whether the proposed indications are convincing and practicable. The presentation and discussion of the plurality of national and international texts and sources give many useful hints even to expert readers.

These sources provide a well-prepared analytical basis of different materials covering many fields, which have grown out of proportion in recent years and which show rich cultural and also regulatory content. These are essential cognitive elements in order to knowingly deal with these issues, which are scarcely acquired in our debate, even though they are often presupposed by those who intervene in the matter.

The second chapter of the essay well emphasizes how in recent years, concerning Sustainable Development and its different economic and social implications, we have seen the dawning, at the various supranational levels, of a network of principles, agreements, practices and even (soft, or scarcely binding) norms that represent a major institutional innovation in the world scenario.

The international indications have not only been a stimulus to theoretical reflection, but have activated a series of interactions between different legal, national and supranational systems with implications that are not yet all perceived. They have nourished intertwined forms of dialogue between different public and private actors of the various systems able to give life to forms of horizontal harmonization between the principles and practices of these systems: a tendency to isomorphism sometimes under trace but no less significant.

An area where this tendency is evident, as I have also been able to investigate personally, is constituted by the social clauses of international trade treaties, whose contents and procedures have manifested significant convergences precisely because of the intertwining and mutual influence of principles and practices coming from this network of different supranational sources. It is the influence of this network that guarantees the acquisition, until recently taken for granted, of the need to consider the various dimensions of sustainability together, not only the original environmental, but also the economic and social dimensions.

The heuristic and political importance of this integrated vision is convincingly illustrated by the author with precise references to its (first) implications. It is for this reason as well that the concept of Sustainability has taken on multiple (and in some cases indeterminate) meanings, presenting itself, following some definitions reported in the text that seem to me significant, as an umbrella principle or as a matrix of useful principles to constitute a window through which labour law looks with a new orientation at the future of its subject-matter. The essay analyzes two possible implications, a strategic and a methodological one, that the application of the principle of sustainability can assume both for the interpretation and for the (possible) evolution of labour law.

Under the first profile, the text discusses the assonance among the values ​​of labour law (in particular solidarity and equality of opportunity) and Sustainable Development. In interpreting and revising its values, our subject-matter has always had to reconcile different interests, the needs of economy and enterprises with those of protection and dignity of work. It has done so with different orientations and outcomes according to the various economic and political contexts, often pressed by contingencies induced by these contexts.

The horizon of Sustainability induces to widen the scopes and terms of the reconciliation of interests, recalling the need not only to emphasize the qualitative aspects of development and work, but to always consider a medium-long term perspective, to take into account the multiplicity of the stakeholders interested in economic, social and environmental issues and, in particular, to practice an approach that achieves intergenerational equity. Adopting this last approach is a real strategic leap for both legislators and social actors, including labour Unions, whose solidarity, even when taking into account general interests, has focused on the destinies of present generations, sometimes to the detriment of future ones (and sometimes even of young people).

According to the author, Sustainable Development reinforces the capabilities approach and together with this, it would contribute to a more dynamic and sustainable labour law. Our subject-matter has tasks that go beyond the traditional ones, not only that of protecting weak part of the employment contract, but also that of social protection: to contribute to the sustainability of development in its social, economic and environmental multiple dimensions, and also to promote the capabilities of workers.

Here we can find controversial issues, raised in fact by the theory of capabilities, which deal with the crisis of subordination and with the possibility of enhancing individual autonomy in the current world of (subordinate but also independent) labour. The recent legislation on agile work, dealt with extensively by the author, can foster a better combination, a true virtuous circle, among personal needs to reconcile one's own hours, flexible organization of companies and reduction of external and internal costs to companies. However, at the same time the law unprecedentedly recognize a major role to individual contract in the regulation of very delicate aspects of the employment relationship, and this is a critical aspect even for workers in the new economy.

The question that cannot be avoided is how to strengthen the capacity of such workers to make the management of this new form of work sustainable, with what new individual rights and what collective support. Furthermore, the theses on capabilities have been criticized for underestimating the importance of collective action for the regulation of labour relations and for the exercise of individual autonomy.

Certainly, the perspectives of Trade Union relations need to be reconsidered no less than those of the individual labour law, because they are challenged by the same structural factors that are at the basis of the crisis of our subject-matter and that directly invest the possibilities and the very meaning of the collective action. But this reconsideration must be conducted with the same convictions needed to ponder on the new job forms and their possible rules.

I think that the principle of Sustainability can also be useful here, because the ambitious goals of reorienting development in all its dimensions can hardly be pursued without the participation, in new ways to be identified, of workers as individuals and their organizations.

The second implication of the sustainability approach - the methodological one - is no less rich than the first of implications for labour law. This approach emphasizes in new ways the value of interdependence, between disciplinary profiles and between different decision-making levels, necessary to grasp the evolution and the sense of development. As far as we are concerned, it is useful to identify the orientations of our subject-matter that are necessary to make it capable of interpreting new realities and responding to the different needs of workers and companies.

Interdependence is one of the fundamental characteristics of modernity and it is also present in by different dimensions, according to social economic choices, geopolitical areas and time sequences. This is why the analytical and proactive approach to Sustainable Development must be "matrix-oriented". Thus it can help labour law go out of the traditional boundaries within which it has developed, the world of subordinate work and, if you will, the working class, on which it has concentrated its choices and the related mediations of interests.

This area has historically promoted not only the cause of work but the well-being of most populations (however, only in advanced countries). But it has become increasingly inadequate with the diversification of social groups and individual fortunes and, on the other hand, with the involvement of entire populations that have been so far excluded in the world scene. All this requires that our subject-matter, as well as its protagonists, broaden their horizon on the different fields indicated by the multiple dimensions of sustainability.

Facing these new areas of action may involve difficult political and even juridical choices, such as those between the needs of growth and of environmental protection that have often been eluded and that are at the origin of persistent conflicts. On another front, the unprecedented implications of markets and global politics must be addressed by the national actors in relation to each other and by the fragile supranational institutions, if both want to contribute to the directions of development where the latter are now decisively determined.

Finally, the prolongation of life and the diversity of its cycles widen and complicate the contents of solidarity between generations; and this also requires new social and economic policies to make these relations sustainable and to avoid the fracture of the generational pact that has held together modern societies so far.

In the third and fourth chapters of the essay, the author presents the implications of the Sustainability approach for some critical areas of our labour law. The enhancement of individual autonomy has already been mentioned above; the pension system is analyzed in the essay by noting the criticalities that make it unsustainable and by pointing to the urgency of interventions to promote intergenerational solidarity.

The flexicurity policies are analyzed underlining how the European design of the latter is in line with the idea of ​​Sustainability, because it reinterprets the balance between the need for flexibility and security in the current context of mobile and transitional markets, even if the implementation practices, especially in the Italian case, have been unbalanced.

Gender and wages inequalities constitute a profound contradiction with respect to equality of opportunity, which is one of the founding principles of Sustainability. The contrast of these inequalities also requires a broadening of the horizons of labour law and its actors, so that they can be mobilized, with the necessary alliances, to make it a central objective of development policies.

The research conducted in the essay allows the author to legitimately ask the question of whether labour law can be a Sustainability law. The question is founded, the answer is uncertain. But that is enough in order to continue investigations like this that can offer promising ideas, as the author also believes, both for the reconsideration of many parts of the current normative texts and for proposing new solutions.

The current context of our Country does not offer easy elements to support these perspectives. However, many of the founding principles of Sustainable Development are already present and active in the institutional fabric and in international sources. They help guide the steps towards the construction of a more modern and supranational law that may be useful to sustainability; and from the fragile indications of international actors, there may be stimulus to reinforce the attempts made in some Countries to undertake a path towards Sustainable Development.




Vuoi saperene di più?

Compila il seguente form. Ti risponderemo il prima possibile!

Privacy: