Tiziano Treu Official Site logo Home Biografia Articoli Guida Lavoro Interviste Libri Notizie Foto & Video Contatti
Diritto del lavoro e globalizzazione

Research on frontier topics in labour law

Research on frontier topics in labour law

At the 2015 World Congress in Cape Town, our International Society launched seven international research groups to work on topics we believed to be particularly important for the future of work and for the challenges they represent in our discipline.

1. Research on frontier topics in labour law


At the 2015 World Congress in Cape Town, our International Society launched seven international research groups to work on topics we believed to be particularly important for the future of work and for the challenges they represent in our discipline. The topics were chosen taking into account our discussions in recent years. We do not claim that the list is exhaustive but we believe they cover some of the crucial issues facing not only the lawyers but also all students of social sciences, and this is confirmed by the work done by the groups themselves.

The main purpose of this international research, and indeed of our tradition, is to draw on the experience and knowledge of the national systems as acquired by the different national associations with a view to providing comparative and interdisciplinary analyses for the international community of academics and practitioners. 

We believe that only in-depth research ─ as objective as possible ─ on the various aspects of the various issues can shed light on a future that appears more than ever uncertain, and much in need of critical thinking. In this way, we can avoid the ideological controversies and simplistic solutions that are unfortunately common in our field, exposed as they are to social tensions and influenced by conflicting interests. Analytical and participatory research is also the basis for putting forward, with all the necessary caveats, suggestions and proposals to national and supranational policy-makers. 

We believe − and I am personally convinced− that despite the radical changes in the world of work and business brought about by globalization and the new digital technologies, the impact of these factors is by no means predetermined. It can be influenced by the decisions of institutions as well as by public and private actors operating in the various areas. Our analyses provide significant examples of such influence and of the scope for our research.  

I would emphasize here, as I have done at other times, the importance of the comparative approach. Although for a hundred years our discipline has been constructed on national foundations, it is now being transformed by the increasing interdependence not only of businesses and financial institutions in various countries, but also of the national, legal and social systems. 

Comparative analysis, if it is to go beyond the mere descriptive juxtaposition of national institutions, is difficult for academics and policy-makers, who until now have concentrated on national problems and have been convinced of the specific character of their solutions. Our Society, with its research and seminars, can provide ideas for innovation in this area and good examples of comparative practices in the field of Labour Law and Industrial Relations.


The complexity of the challenges and experiences inherent in the various systems does not make for easy solutions or quick answers.

General analyses of major economic and social trends may also be inadequate if they are not functional.  What is required is in-depth analysis if we want to grasp the complex reality of labour law and labour relations and understand the answers to common challenges of the different national systems.

Specific analyses of this type are important in a period of rapid and uncertain transition in which partial innovations in some areas, which are not taken into account by (over)-general surveys, may be important in highlighting current trends. 

The research topics explored by our groups are indicative of the changes − some would say the crisis − affecting our discipline. Indeed, the analyses raise questions about fundamental aspects of the regulatory structures handed down from the past. The challenge concerns above all the role of the State as regulator of labour relations and the labour market. This role must now be performed in settings that go beyond national boundaries, by entities lacking traditional state powers but acting under negotiated and, in the broad sense, public instruments, ranging from transnational collective agreements to social clauses in trade agreements.  

In addition, the international scene is characterized by epoch-making phenomena, such as mass migration, which presents enormous problems for the regulation of working conditions, seriously testing the effectiveness of existing laws and even representing a threat to human life. Other aspects of security, including the reception and integration of migrants, are covered by fragile and inadequate inter-State agreements, as we have seen with the dramatic events taking place in Europe, with particular reference to refugees and illegal immigrants. The research report presented by Prof. Kubra Dogan Yenisey deals with the complex problems posed by these migrations, pointing out the lack of binding international regulation and, here again, the key role of nation-states, which until now has been expressed in contradictory and often conflicting solutions. The report also shows how migration has led to the conflict between the rights of migrants and those of local workers becoming a central issue in labour law. 


2. A crisis of legal categories 

The issues of the quality of labour relations and corporate productivity have assumed unprecedented and potentially disruptive dimensions in our field, as a result of the processes of decentralization affecting industrial relations and production and social systems generally. 

These trends accentuate aspects of corporatization of both collective and individual labour relations, with far-reaching implications for border issues such welfare and the connection between work and productivity. At the same time, they open up new possibilities for trade-union activity and for innovative management in the use of technologies in corporate organization and in the regulation of web-based employment.

But the issue that is central to our thinking, affecting many specific aspects, of the kind we have just mentioned, is the very concept of work and the legal categories in which it needs to be framed for the purposes of regulation. This is the issue tackled by our first research group coordinated by Prof. Humberto Villasmil Prieto, working on the topic of “Informal and non-standard employment”. The terminology, commonly used in international sources, is non-technical and covers a wide range of circumstances.

Cutting across all our research subjects, this issue emerges from the discussions of the other groups and from a good Numbers of our seminar.

Our discipline is now concerned above all with the many forms of employment that differ from those prevalent in the 20th century on which our subject was constructed (i.e. subordinate employment, especially in a corporate setting), and in this area most of the research has concentrated. But the expression “informal employment” also refers to those activities which are developing in the sectors of the informal economy. 

As the ILO reminds us, in emerging countries and societies these sectors account for more than 75 per cent of business activity and of workers in employment. A specific report is devoted to this topic. But I would point out straight away that informal sectors and informal jobs are Aldo present in so-called “advanced” economies. This coexistence of ancient and modern is one of the deepest cleavages in economic and social systems, raising the question of the effectiveness of our employment and social security arrangements. Indeed, as European trade unions have stressed with great concern, the most recent forms of “crowd working” may lead to the uncontrolled spread of informal employment (ETUC, Resolution of 8/9 June 2016). 

Our comparative analyses paint a picture of persistent uncertainty (Weiss) and of considerable diversity in the solutions adopted by different countries. The impact of the new digital technologies on the organization of work and businesses is the extreme manifestation of this uncertainty. 

This is certainly true where the volume of work is concerned. Forecasts that most traditional jobs will disappear in the near future are probably exaggerated. Yet the impact is bound to grow. Throughout the world, there has been an explosion of Gig economy jobs based on digital platforms, the extreme example of “anytime anywhere” working.  In California, which is often in the forefront of new trends, 400,000 Uber drivers have mobilized and taken legal action against the corporate platform. It is estimated that there are already more than 14 million web-based workers active in the USA.  


In any case, the effects of digital innovations on employment are bound to grow, especially in traditional repetitive jobs . 

It is significant that, in Europe, the threat from the digital revolution has re-opened the debate not only on flexible working hours, but also on their reduction. The recently renegotiated contract of German metalworkers entitles them to reduce (for two years) their weekly working hours to 28 (with a partial reduction in salary) or, if they prefer, to return to a normal working week of 35 hours. In return, the employers are permitted to exercise greater flexibility in organizing working time. Part-time working (not always voluntary) is on the increase, emerging as a widespread system of work-sharing, often within the family (N.B. Holland).

Over and above, the total availability of employment, the forms and quality of labour will be affected by unprecedented changes, particularly where repetitive work is concerned, leading to the globalization of jobs (S. Scarpetta, Employment Outlook 2016). The change is so profound that the inadequacy not only of traditional regulations but even of the categories on which labour law are based is becoming evident, first and foremost subordinate employment. This is not just a matter for theoretical jurists, since the uncertainties are beginning to affect the rulings of the tribunals.


3. Gig Economy jobs 

European judges, like their Common Law counterparts, are divided between those who try to include Gig economy workers in the subordinate employment category and provide them with rights pertaining to that status and those who, on the contrary, emphasize their autonomy. But all of them acknowledge the novelty of such cases, due to the fact that they often combine aspects of both autonomos and subordinate status. Understandably, some judges, especially those applying the Common Law, avoid judging their cases within one of the two traditional categories and concentrate on the workers’ needs for protection (accidents, minimum wage standards and so on). The cases of Uber and Foodora point to a more general trend. There will be a degree of autonomy in the more advanced forms of subordinate employment and a degree of dependency in the freelance jobs spawned by the internet. 

I have been convinced for a long time that in order to get a handle on this trend and provide an adequate response, we must pay more attention to the need to protect workers in these new forms of employment (without forgetting the old ones) than to refer to the traditional  categories.

We, too, have started to research on this subject. The aim is to find a common basis of rules which meets the fundamental needs of working people, drawing inspiration for the decent work standards set by the International Labour Organization. 

Given the variety of these jobs, there is little point in seeking “quick fixes” which, is confirmed by our comparative studies. At the same time, it does not help the introduction of many different types of contracts.

Many European judges have interpreted the once-rigid notion of subordinate employment in a more elastic way so as to adapt it to many of these jobs, which, though they may be formally included in an enterprise’s structures, all show combinations of dependency and autonomy. 

Legislators have adopted a similar attitude. Some have created intermediate categories of employment contracts under various  names: parasubordinated jobs, economically dependent employment, relations similar to subordinate employment, etc. To these are applied some, but not all, of the traditional protections afforded to subordinate employees: in particular, minimum wages, safety standards, social security, accident insurance, etc.  But the creation of these new categories has not clarified the dividing lines between them, and such regulations have proved difficult to implement.


4. From legal definitions to the modulation of protections

 More appropriate, as I see it, is the solution adopted by the French lawmakers, who have come up with a general response focusing on a number of essential rights and protections, not claiming to provide legal definitions of digital employment but abandoning the all-or-nothing logic inherent in the rigid traditional categories.

One possible route, to some extent taken by Italian lawmakers, is to leave it to collective bargaining to redefine and clarify the borders between different forms of employment, while adapting the way they are treated to the specific requirements of individual types of work and business.  

There are similar difficulties in identifying frameworks for the various occupations, because digital technologies are changing the relationship between intelligent machines and the workers who operate them, with the consequence that the content of traditional jobs is radically changed and the very concept of a contractual framework is rendered obsolete. This confirms my, and others’, conviction that the strengthening of workers’ professional identity and skills, with targeted investment in training, is the best strategy for reacting positively to the challenges of technological innovation and promoting equality of opportunity in the digital era (FMI). 



5. Criteria for selecting  protections

The subordinate employment category still corresponds to a large number of jobs in the various sectors of the economy and one cannot simply declare it out of date from an exaggerated love of all things new.

But regarding it as an exclusive descriptive filter would obscure the various forms of working activity that are rapidly increasing in modern economies, as well as the need to regulate and protect them.

The legal materials provided by our comparison confirm what has already been said: that changes in the forms of employment have been met with different regulatory and social responses ─ often far removed from traditional solutions ─ from the various legal systems.

In this respect, the guidance of the European Commission regarding the most controversial forms of digital employment is significant. While mentioning the possible use of subordinate employment criteria for settling so-called “platform workers” cases and disputes, the Commission merely invites member States to ensure that workers benefit from “fair working conditions” and “adequate and sustainable social protection”, identified by considering “the different needs and the innovative nature of collaborative business models”. 

It is clear that this is an open ruling, which suggests that research should be focused more on the regulatory needs of the jobs concerned than on the traditional descriptive categories. It indicates that two main factors need to be considered: on the one hand, people’s need to enjoy fair working conditions and adequate protection; on the other band, the innovative character of these business models. The reference to their cooperative character seems to allude to certain aspects of the “sharing economy”, which are in any case far from being present in all cases subject to discussion or dispute.

This opens up a field of research for jurists and policy-makers, whose task is to identify criteria for regulating such new arrangements, over and above the need for fairness and social considerations. The aim is to avoid a situation in which, having cut loose from the traditional descriptive categories, we merely register the existence of fluid boundaries between different cases and hand out protections at random without any theoretical basis.

As we have seen, the mobility and variation of individual cases mean that rigid legal interventions are ineffective. Flexible regulation as established in collective labour agreements may be more practical, provided that it truly represents the needs of these new types of jobs.

In any case, the guidelines for regulation must be inspired by the general principles of the legal system, as embedded in national constitutions , and European and international charters of rights. 


6. Importance of basic standards

Of particular importance in dealing with these new working arrangements, which represent a frontier zone in labour law, is the development of basic standards corresponding to the concept of decent work championed by the International Labour Organization. 

The ILO’s basic standards are of different kinds. Some are concerned with rights relating to freedom of association and trade-union autonomy, recognized in many countries but still often disputed. Many social rights need to be spelled out in regulations implementing legislation or collective agreements, which determine their content, primarily the right to fair pay for work done. This has assumed even more central importance all over the world because of the competitive pressures on businesses and the cost of labour, resulting in the previously unknown phenomenon of the “working poor”.

More recently, new rights, both individual and social, have assumed growing importance, such as the right to on-going training, and ─ following the spread of new digital technologies ─ the right to privacy in the workplace (as well as elsewhere) and the right of workers operating on line to disconnect from the web under certain conditions. 

These standards are becoming more important at present because of the diversification of employment into forms that often do not correspond to traditional legal categories. This reinforces the need, already recognized in theory, to identify a “hard core” of rules and protections applicable to all working activities, whatever their legal status. The need is for a common core expressing the universal principles of the dignity of human labour. The translation of these principles into the various legal systems has to be an essential policy objective if we are to provide a unifying basis for the fragmented jobs of the future and free them from the danger  of deregulation or of lack of regulation.

In reality, an effort to adapt and select protections is also required for many jobs performed within or alongside subordinate employment patterns, but which are distinguished by new characteristics that make many of the traditional rules inapplicable. Think, for instance, of the forms of “smart working” already widespread in many businesses, which not only accentuate the autonomous aspects of the work being done but also remove them from the traditional of time and place.

The changing geography of work calls for a plurality of innovative solutions in the regulation of labour relations and, as we shall see, in other areas of our discipline, from labour market management to social security. The complexity of the new working arrangements requires “tailor-made” labour law on several levels, based on common rules and adapted to the specific needs of the various forms of activity.


7. Regulation of the economy and of informal employment 

The establishment of basic standards may also be significant for tackling the widespread phenomenon of informal economy jobs that are non-compliant or borderline in respect of legal provisions. Such jobs are also largely outside the scope of collective labour agreements. Experience in various countries confirms the difficulty involved in formalizing the informal economy and the weakness of both incentives and repressive measures in achieving this end.

Attempts made in some countries, including Italy, using various contractual incentives to harmonize informal working conditions with those prevalent in the regular labour market have been unsuccessful. 

If this objective is to be achieved, interventions are needed that go beyond the usual employment-related measures and rules. They must tackle the economic and social context in which the informal economy develops, not only backward areas but also modern sectors affected by the new technologies, such as logistics.  

These interventions should aim to foster both economic and institutional and social development, supporting legality, the formation of capital and the strengthening of social networks. Specific initiatives have been recommended by the ILO to remove the obstacles hindering the formalization and growth of the activities in question. We might mention the simplification of bureaucratic procedures for setting up and running businesses, and for managing workers, as well as measures to facilitate access to the resources needed for this purpose: financial services, information and consultancy on business and employment opportunities, advice on how to compete for public contracts, and support for managerial training. 

In areas directly connected with employment, it is vitally important to improve inspection services, which are almost everywhere underdeveloped, training staff to rise to the challenge of preventing and monitoring illegal activity. It is in any case recognized that this type of intervention is insufficient in itself and needs to be integrated with a set of preventive measures and incentives to encourage legality.

A more direct intervention is needed in respect of informal or irregular employment in decentralized production processes (contracting and subcontracting chains), which is widespread even in advanced sectors of the economy. Many legal systems have introduced forms of more or less extensive co-responsibility incumbent on the lead firms in decentralized arrangements, with penalties for non-compliance with labour and social security standards on the part of contractors and subcontractors.

Interventions to regularize informal employment arrangements also need to be adapted to the economic and social context. They may require a gradual approach to the process and different levels of harmonization, and should aim for the enforcement of basic standards, rather than an unrealistic alignment with wages in established sectors of the economy. Acceptance of a certain degree of regulatory differentiation may be necessary to achieve effective results and improve the rules over time.

The changes in employment that have disrupted the traditional categories of labour law have had a no less direct impact on social security arrangements. 

The reasons for and implications of this change in social security provision have been studied by a specific research group. They were presented by our colleague Prof. Marhold at the European Congress held in Prague in September 2017 and are now further  developed here in Turin.


8. Changes in social security: financial sustainability and social fairness

I will simply mention aspects of this change which are more directly connected with the transformations we have previously analysed in the rules governing employment relationships.

In the field of social security, too, legislators in many countries have introduced reforms of the traditional systems in response to new circumstances: first of all, a reduction in the financial resources available for spending on social security, which was already a factor prior to the crisis and has been aggravated by it; secondly, the growing volatility affecting employment, which has reduced the tax base on which many social security provisions depend, from pensions to income support for the unemployed; finally, the radical demographic changes associated with lengthening life expectancy, often combined with falling birth rates.

National reforms have responded to these challenges with differing strategies and results, but with the chief aim of ensuring the financial sustainability of the principal protections and of the social security system as a whole.

The results have been less satisfactory when it comes to ensuring the sustainability and fairness of social protection measures. In many cases, as shown by official EU and OECD surveys, financial sustainability has been achieved to the detriment of fairness for current beneficiaries, and even more so for those who will benefit in the future.

The dramatic consequences are inequality and poverty, which have increased particularly among the younger generations, to the point of threatening the intergenerational pact that has so far sustained our welfare systems.

Complex strategies are required to ensure both the financial sustainability and the fairness of social security provisions. The aim of economic interventions should be to foster growth and enhance the quality of employment, so as to support the social security mechanisms that depend on these factors. The connection between employment and social security may be more or less direct depending on the structures of the various provisions, but in any case it is fundamental.


9. Beyond insurance – based schemes 

At the same time, traditional social security schemes, in particular those that are insurance-based, need to be reformed. Like the traditional rules governing labour relations, they were established on the assumption of a stable labour market and stable jobs. Today they need to be recalibrated to reflect changes in employment, above all the fragmentation and frequent interruptions and transitions in people’s employment records.

Keeping the old schemes unchanged is bound to jeopardize the fairness of social protection for all non-standard jobs, and this is already happening. 

The necessary changes, already under way in some countries, are many and various, and often have parallels with those we have already indicated for the rules governing labour relations. 

The first line of approach, in some European countries, has been to set aside the category-based arrangements of many social protection mechanisms and adopt a universalist philosophy, extending some basic provisions to all forms of work, including non-standard ones.  

Another measure, first introduced some time ago but gradually spreading, has been to take into account for pension purposes periods when a person has not been able to work for personal reasons (sickness, accidents, parental leave, and so on) or because of economic circumstances (unemployment). 

Similar measures have been adopted in some countries to support the tax base of part-time workers. This type of employment has been neglected in the past, and not only where social security is concerned, because it was regarded as marginal. But its rapid spread in modern economies has made it necessary to review its status, to ensure that part-timers to be treated fairly in terms of remuneration and social protection. 

A further and more radical correction of traditional schemes has been to largely disassociate social security benefits from the work performed by the beneficiary.

Some countries now provide pension benefits that depend only on a person’s citizenship status, or that are commensurate with the number of years worked but do not reflect the amount of contributions paid in. 

The common factor in all these measures is that the set aside the commutative principle of insurance-based schemes and bring in the principle of solidarity, thus introducing into the system redistributive elements intended to ensure not only greater financial sustainability but also more fairness in social security provision.

These corrections to social security schemes intended to ensure fairness, especially for non-typical workers and irregular career trajectories, aim to slow the tendency in many countries for all or many of the forms of social protection to shift into the area of welfare.

The distinction between the social security and welfare systems is still important, though the boundaries have become blurred. The distinction is sanctioned by some national Constitutions, including the Italian one, which distinguishes between the right to maintenance and social assistance of citizens who are unfit to work and lacking the means of livelihood and the right of workers to financial support in the event of accidents, sickness, invalidity, old age and redundancy. 

The difference is important in terms of the level of benefits provided: welfare benefits are generally less generous and have not been increased in recent years. The same is true of the circumstances in which benefits are payable. Welfare benefits are conditional on means testing, which in some countries has become so rigorous as to reduce access to benefits or cause beneficiaries to decide not to apply for them.


10. Minimum wage and combatting poverty

The inability of existing income-support systems to respond to the needs of people in difficulty, and the spread of various forms of poverty, has led almost all European countries to introduce some form of minimum wage. Though differing widely, these measures to combat poverty have maintained the approach, common to other forms of assistance and welfare, of requiring the beneficiaries, more or less bindingly, to engage in work, training or other socially useful activities.

Proposals to introduce a generalized and unconditional citizen’s (or basic) income have been widely discussed. Limited experiments have been conducted, with unclear results, but have not yet been adopted on a large scale. 

An apparently insuperable obstacle is the cost of such schemes, especially if, as Prof. Marhold’ s report illustrates, they are viewed in conjunction with the other welfare measures currently forming part of the system. The adoption of a minimum income in addition to the existing provisions would involve an increase in social spending that would be difficult to sustain. On the other hand, its introduction instead of the other measures might well increase, rather than decrease, social inequalities, because well-off people are more capable than the poor of accessing the various social protection benefits.

The analysis conducted up to this point confirms the complexity of the connections between the various social security benefits and the dynamics of the labour market, and points up the need for a better understanding of these connections if we are to establish effective coordination between the policy measures adopted in both areas.

The fragmentation of work patterns requires that labor policies adopt new instruments capable of guaranteeing employment continuity in the variation of job positions. On the other hand welfare policies will be challenged to sustain employment transitions with new more focused measures, in particular services and income support directed to promote re employment of unemployed workers and employment of inactive persons, paid leaves for periods of inactivity due to personal reasons (not only parenthood, illness, work accidents, but also professional upgrading), personal services aimed at facilitating work life balance and professional and territorial mobility. 

In this perspective welfare measures are integrated with labor policies with the aim of helping them in the difficult task of fighting precariousness and promoting quality employment.



11. Labour policies and welfare policies 

As an example of the close relationship between the two areas and the need to coordinate strategies, I would simply mention the spread in almost all countries of some form of legal minimum wage. This is a measure that combines the function of paying a wage as a reward for work done with the social function of ensuring a level of income that meets the needs of workers and therefore prevents and combats poverty. It is apparent that this function converges with the functions of the social security provisions we have been examining, again no longer inspired by commutative principles alone but by principles of solidarity. 

The convergence between these two areas of strategy is also evident in the introduction of minimum income   measures. The objective of combatting poverty now concerns large numbers of workers who cannot make ends meet, either because they are on low wages or because they have  come to the end of their entitlement to the unemployment benefits provided by workers’ insurance schemes. 

As we have said, workers’ insurance-based protection schemes are still distinct from general welfare measures, but the dividing line is becoming blurred. Some insurance-based protection schemes are relaxing the connection with workers’ employment records and, at the same time, welfare provisions such as the minimum income are involving large groups of workers at risk of poverty.

The close relationship between these functions is also working in another way, in the sense that, as well as performing their traditional compensatory function, some social security provisions are intended to encourage beneficiaries to be proactive in the labour market. 

The fact is that traditional welfare measures are also open to further enrichments, which we are already seeing to some extent, when they are used in as forms of social investment, intended not only to defend certain levels of income, but also to promote personal capacities and human development.  

We have several times noted that the issues of regulation and policy covered by our analysis have attracted different solutions in different countries, and this diversity confirms the importance of the choices made by national institutions and actors in responding to the global changes taking place.


12. The role of the State in globalization 

In recent years, we have also seen growing State interventionism in many sectors of labour law and social security, and even in the regulation of industrial relations, an area which has always been particularly resistant to outside interference. 

Only some of these legislative interventions have followed common trajectories. On the whole, they have accentuated regulatory and policy divergences, even in relatively homogeneous areas long committed to convergence, such as the European Union, to the point of taking on an unprecedented nationalistic character, even in the social sphere.

The comparative analysis presented by Prof. Jesús Cruz Villalón and Prof. Maria Katia Garcia Landaburu confirms that the role of the State as an actor in regulation and policy continues to be decisive and without competition, (partly) because globalization has not produced public organizations endowed with regulatory powers akin to those of the State. 

But these analyses also show that the State’s role has been weakened by a number of convergent factors. On the one hand, competition between States and the transfer of many essential decisions affecting community life to settings much broader than state institutions and policies have reduced the scope for independent decision-making on the part on nation states.  The factors behind the current changes brook no frontiers and operate with an unprecedented intensity in increasing interdependence between the various national systems. 

On the other, technological and social changes have affected the efficacy of the regulatory and policy instruments with which States have operated, primarily legislation and partly collective bargaining. It is clear that the weakening of the authority of nation states also represents a crisis for traditional regulatory instruments and legal categories. Not only are traditional legislative sources losing their prestige in favour of “soft” regulations or general principles, but the new transnational sources referred to above are developing along uncertain lines that reflect the weaknesses and/or disagreements between the actors concerned. 

One of the most discussed manifestations of this crisis is the transformation of legislative sources occasioned by the emergence of various forms of “soft” law.  It is no coincidence that these new regulatory forms have been used widely in the regulation of various kinds of supranational relationship (and not only relation to labour matters), where the regulatory authority of nation states cannot be exercised. In the EU system, soft-law techniques have been adopted as being best suited to laying down guidelines for the regulation of emergent new forms of employment on the cutting edge of the labour market. 

The regulatory crisis has also affected collective labour agreements, especially at national level, which have traditionally reproduced the regulatory features of national legislation. Meanwhile, forms of intervention are taking root in negotiation at company level that are midway between “micro” regulation  and the often bilateral management of labour relations in the day-to-day administration of employment contracts.

The consequence, noted by many observers, is that a plurality of both forms and levels of regulation − national, international and, on our continent, European − have begun to operate in our field. In addition, we have seen the development of regional and local regulatory sources, which also affect labour issues, encouraged by the decentralization of the economy and company relations.  

The multi-level character of regulation is a further urgent reason for continuing with our national surveys and analyses, and above all our comparative work. The theory, still held by many, that different systems cannot be compared is invalidated by the factual evidence, and is also undermined by the (weak) international authorities. Rather, the closeness, and often the osmosis, between provisions in different systems in some ways changes the very nature of the comparison. It is no longer just a matter of observing the various legal and social models with an attentive and “distant” eye, but of detecting the influences and interrelations between these models and/or sectors of them as they appear day by day in the economic and social life of all countries.  

Comparative analysis of the various national systems and the solutions they have devised is not only an essential tool for acquiring theoretical knowledge but also the basis for resolving the problems with which enterprises, trade-unions and institutional managers have to wrestle. These problems, which determine economic and social decisions, are more and more frequently transnational, despite the current nationalistic reactions we are seeing, even in the labour law policies of various countries. 

While it is true that the origins and repercussions of labour regulations are manifested at national level, its effectiveness, now and even more so in the future, is not ensured  unless such regulation and state action are able to face up to the challenges presented by international markets.

At the same time, the projection of regulations beyond national border is limited in its effectiveness by the fact that the instruments defining and implementing the rules still depend on national authorities and powers.

Our comparative analyses show the results of experimentation with various vectors and techniques for regulating supranational labour relations.


13. Instruments for international labour regulation: social clauses in trade agreements

The social clauses in international trade agreements are widely used instruments, directly involving the regulatory and administrative role of the State. Modifying a well-known formula, one might say that such clauses have the consensual form of a contract, but an inter-state substance that is accentuated in the implementation phase. Their implementation is in fact based on relations between public bureaucracies. It is free of legal interventions and, when verification by third parties is required, recourse is had to arbitration procedures, which are embedded in the public procedure but maintain a private, often not impartial  character. 

As the report of Prof. Perulli and Prof. Bellace illustrate, clauses of this kind are included in an increasing number of international agreements and have evolved in terms of content, expressing increasingly stringent commitments by the parties concerned, particularly regarding compliance with the ILO’s core labour standards . But – as prof. Bellace argues -  the link  of social  clauses to the  ILO  conventions  on fundamental  rights is often  still uncertain. Procedures for the implementation of these commitments are also expressed in more complex formulae.

Most recently, the agreements between the EU and Canada (CETA) and between the EU and Japan (EPA) include significant procedural innovations, providing for panels of experts and the involvement of civil society to provide comments and opinions on the implementation of the clauses concerned, and even setting up impartial specialized tribunals to settle disputes with private investors. (N.B. ISOS).

But such procedures continue to be the weakest part of these instruments, because their enforcement depends essentially on the initiative of the governments stipulating the agreements (and in actual fact on their bureaucrats).  

In addition, public opinion in many countries continues to view trade agreements with suspicion, because there is often a lack of transparency in the way in which they are concluded, and because of doubts as to whether the social clauses afford protection against the risk of such agreements opening the way for a “race to the bottom” where social and environmental standards are concerned.

At the same time, the very existence and usefulness of present forms of multilateral negotiation of the rules of international trade are now being challenged by the renascent protectionism championed by many countries, first and foremost the United States.

In reality, as the Perulli report notes, the justification for social clauses cannot be solely economic. They need to be seen in a wider context, as instruments promoting sustainable development and human rights.  


14. Continued: codes of conduct and transnational collective agreements

Other vehicles for the international regulation of labour relations are driven by the social partners. Some, such as codes of conduct, are unilateral initiatives on the part of multinational enterprises; others, for instance various kinds of collective labour agreement, are bilateral in character.

Codes of conduct have gained traction and been enriched with content to the point of including principles similar to those of international charters of human rights. But they continue to lack binding legal efficacy and their impact depends on companies’ internal monitoring procedures, and therefore on their determination to comply with them. More effective than these procedures has been the pressure of public opinion and the civil organizations of the countries involved, whose criticisms can damage companies’ reputations. 

The development of various forms of transnational collective agreement would seem to offer more promising prospects, as we shall see from the report on this topic (report by Prof. F. Guarriello). 

Some multinationals, particularly those based in Europe, maybe influenced by the social and institutional context, have consulted trade-union organizations in preparing their codes of conduct and have concluded a growing number of collective agreements with the same organizations or, more often, with European Works Councils (EWCs).

The rapid increase in the number of these agreements has been encouraged by the tendency towards the decentralization of industrial relations to the company level. But they are limited in their effectiveness because collective labour agreements do not have a common legal status in Europe. At the same time, international trade-union organizations which sign collective agreements, for instance with employers, have not received sufficient powers from their national associations to represent them with binding effect. 

Here again, the role of the State may be decisive in compensating for the weakness of these agreements by introducing innovative regulatory and promotional instruments.

In any case, these international agreements, like other international sources, are effective only within national legal systems. In the absence of the common legal status of a supranational source, States can only ascribe legal force to these agreements in accordance with the regulations that apply to national collective agreements. They can do so by adopting regulatory and support measures that take account of the various features of the supranational agreements, which often include provisions that are different and more specialized than those of their national counterparts.

Many legal systems, and not only in Europe, ascribe to collective agreements stipulated by the most representative social partners effects beyond the sphere of the partners themselves (erga omnes). Ascribing to agreements stipulated by supranational organizations legal effects that apply to participating national associations and their members would be a different kind of extension, but justifiable if deemed useful for the regulation of relations concerning the sphere of representation of the stipulating parties, albeit operating in different national contexts.

A measure of this kind would give the supranational rules greater effectiveness than could be achieved by international organizations exercising their (weak) powers of influence over the national associations that form their membership. 

Collective agreements concluded by multinationals with trade unions or works councils can have a direct impact on the regulation of labour relations through the implementing decisions taken by such enterprises, if, in exercising their executive powers, they take into account the obligations assumed under the agreements concerned. 


15. Instruments for making transnational collective agreements more effective

National legal systems can support the negotiation of transnational agreements by recognizing the binding nature of these agreements for the stipulating parties, in particular the contractual obligations assumed by the concerned multinational enterprises. The effects of such recognition, and the enforcement of the contractual obligations, will depend on the specific national regulations and can be arranged in different ways  These modalities need to be explored through legal analysis, a project still to be undertaken.

Moreover, national support can be organized in advance of negotiations, in the ways already adopted in some legal systems, i.e. by attributing negotiating and participatory powers to the workers’ representatives in these enterprises, as provided for by German co-management regulations.

Measures of this kind would strengthen the capacity of worker’s representatives to co-determine working conditions in the various units of multinational enterprises and would support the scaling-up to transnational level of virtuous labour relations of the kind currently practised under some agreements between multinationals and European works councils.

There have been few practical tests of the legal verification of the effects of these transnational agreements, because the parties tend to settle disputes relating to the application of the agreements via internal grievance procedures. National tribunals are reluctant to rule on questions that have arisen in other legal systems because this would imply recognition of the extra-territorial efficacy of labour legislation.

The collective bargaining undertaken in groups of enterprises may be fertile ground for experimenting with innovative solutions in this area. Group agreements can influence the behaviour of the various group units, even if they are located in different countries, taking advantage of the close ties within the group, especially if managed by the group’s dominant enterprise.

Such ties may also be leveraged on the external legal level by taking advantage of the tendency already present to some extent in many legal systems of ascribing unitary legal status to a group of enterprises, in particular attributing responsibility for the behaviour of individual group companies to the dominant enterprise.

Interestingly, one of the few instances of the transnational efficacy of collective agreements concerns a group-related dispute initiated by a Korean trade union to contest the dismissal of an employee in violation of a collective group agreement. The action was taken against the American parent company of the Korean subsidiary. The judge, sitting in New York, admitted his competence by acknowledging the violation of the collective agreement, and undue interference with the local management by the parent company, though he did not feel able to confirm the responsibility of the parent company due to a procedural  exception.   

If a ruling of this kind were confirmed, the unitary status of the group, already recognized in various aspects of case law within national legal systems, including in Italy, would be extended “across borders ”. This would be a very important innovation, because it would confirm the capacity of transnational group agreements to be used as a source of regulation of labour relations outside the limits and without the involvement of national legal systems.

To conclude this point, experience indicates that, in the absence of a supranational authority, the development of more effective social rules in global economic relations must rely on a large number of different implementing strategies and instruments. These can be deployed either by public institutions, national governments and international institutions applying their own legal arrangements, treaties, conventions and regulations, or by corporate organizations using codes of conduct, guidelines and collective agreements. The weakness of existing international bodies with competence in social matters limits their capacity to contribute to the social regulation of globalization. It is therefore important that we use the existing instruments as best we can by agreeing to work for the convergence and international application of at least the fundamental social principles and standards.  


16. The impact of decentralization on the nature and content of collective bargaining

The group researching “Organization, productivity and wellbeing at work” has confirmed that the current changes in the world of work and business are exerting strong pressures to decentralize collective bargaining, even in European countries which have traditionally had arrangements for nationwide category-based, or at least “multi-employer” bargaining. 

The trend towards the decentralization of production and contractual negotiation has general implications, indicating the (renewed or acquired) centrality of enterprises in the national and global economy, especially since this decentralization is not only ‘spatial’ and technical, but is also becoming normative, giving the enterprise a central role in the ‘system of market regulation’ (Bavaro).  

National legislators who have intervened in this field have encouraged the process of contractual decentralization, albeit on differing terms and with different impacts on the system.

Some have introduced radical changes, to the point of overturning the traditional hierarchy, ascribing primary importance to company collective agreements and giving them general powers to amend agreements reached at a higher level. Others, as in France, have adopted more nuanced positions, ascribing priority to decentralized company agreements in regulating matters not reserved for national agreements, but at the same time establishing an obligation on employers to bargain collectively in respect of the majority of working conditions.

The ability of central organizations to control decentralized processes also differs considerably. In some countries, such as Germany and Italy, it has been significant, at least in strong economic sectors and in medium-to-large enterprises, and has proved able to limit the scope of deleterious company derogations. 

But in every case this trend has resulted in a substantial alteration of the system and of the nature of the agreements concerned. National agreements have tended to become framework contracts, concentrating on regulating wage levels and minimum standards. The role of central bargaining in coordinating the fundamental employment regulations in the various sectors, in particular wages, nevertheless remains important, because a coordinated contractual system, as the OECD points out, results in fewer imbalances in remuneration and better occupational conditions, especially for more vulnerable groups (OECD Employment Outlook 2018).  

Decentralized bargaining tends to be more managerial than normative in the true sense, and in any case firm-specific, i.e. reflecting the priorities and needs of the individual company. 

Local conditions and the quality of industrial relations are key in determining the significance of this development in decentralized bargaining and assessing whether it leads to better regulation of employment contracts. Is it more effective in reconciling the interest of the parties because it is takes more account of the needs of each as expressed in local circumstances? Or do company agreements concluded in conditions of unequal power relationships tend to favour company rationality as opposed to the interests of workers?

In the more advanced companies, collective bargaining and trade-union activity generally are often in competition with innovative management in defining working and welfare conditions and creating a rational atmosphere that engages the loyalty of employees. 


17. Payment by results and corporate welfare

Two particularly significant areas in this respect are bonus systems and company welfare schemes.

Forms of payment by results are part of the history of industrial relations, from traditional piecework, which we find reproduced in the new working practices of the gig economy, to the many variants of bonus payments, linked to sometimes very sophisticated indicators of productivity and company profitability. 

These forms of remuneration have always given rise to controversy, because while on the one hand they may stimulate workers’ motivation and contribute to flexible cost management, on the other they transfer part of the risk involved in running the company to the workers themselves.

In actual fact, the significance and impact of bonuses depends on various factors: the types of indicators chosen, the magnitude of the variable as opposed to the fixed amount of remuneration, and the degree of influence and participation of the workers concerned in the definition and administration of the bonuses. 

The trend towards contractual decentralization emphasizes their importance, because it is within companies themselves that these systems of remuneration are mostly devised and developed, and the quality of relations between the parties involved is therefore the key factor in determining the outcomes.

Research confirms this. Indeed, it indicates that the effectiveness of bonus schemes in achieving their stated objective of promoting company productivity cannot be assessed simply by observing the design and internal dynamics of the bonuses, but must take into account the overall context of relations between the parties, i.e. the degree of participation of all those concerned in the management of the incentive schemes. 

Forms of welfare that supplement public provision also go back a long way in many systems, but they have acquired different content and new importance in recent years because of the inadequacies of public social security provision, and due to the spread of new and more personal needs among workers.

In many countries, including those with a consolidated public welfare system, forms of company benefits, unilaterally accorded or negotiated, have become an important component of the social protection system. As a result, this system is now based on two pillars in addition to public provision: collective welfare and private insurance schemes . These two pillars have mobilized growing amounts of private social spending in order to meet needs that in many cases would otherwise remain unmet.

Research shows that supplementary welfare benefits can contribute not only to the welfare of workers and to company productivity, but also, if well distributed and targeted, to the overall efficiency of the system, in particular in promoting a mixed service economy. It generally emerges that these positive effects depend on benefits being geared to priority social needs not met by the public system and, in addition, on their being distributed in a balanced way throughout the system, and in particular in small enterprises. 

Careful selection of priorities for this kind of welfare, and balanced distribution of the resources necessary to sustain it, are necessary conditions if such provisions are to supplement the system of protections in a balanced way and not increase inequalities.

Achieving these conditions depends on their management by the social partners, together with policy decisions taken under the various legal systems. In many countries, the development of company welfare measures has been supported by different kinds of tax incentives. In some cases, as in Italy, the arrangements must be negotiated between the parties or managed through participatory procedures, in which case the incentives are increased. These forms of welfare do in fact lend themselves to be managed in a cooperative way and have proved to be particularly appreciated if the beneficiaries are informed and involved in the way they work.

The innovations introduced in the two areas mentioned above have implications not only for the very concept of an enterprise, but also for the content of the employment relationship.

The traditional exchange arrangement ─ fixed remuneration for stable work ─ has been changing as a result of new developments both in the ever-more-variable forms of employment and in the ways in which they are rewarded. 

The departure from the traditional exchange arrangement is particularly marked when the parameters of these forms of remuneration depend not directly on the quality and quantity of the work performed, but on external factors connected with the company’s economic and/or financial performance, for example sharing in company profits, possibly effected through the distribution of shares and stock options.

Contractual welfare measures inject a further variant into the relationship, because they do not translate into monetary payments but into benefits in the form of services. Unlike bonuses, these measures are not direct incentives. They nevertheless benefit the worker, in meeting personal or collective needs relating to the welfare of the individual and his family. We might say that they enrich the content of the relationship through an exchange of a social, rather than a market-related, benefits.

This innovation corresponds to a general evolution of the concept of remuneration, beyond  that  of mere payment of  work done.  

This development of welfare is a further manifestation of the social enrichment   of the exchange present in the employment contract, because it associates welfare with the worker’s needs, which can also be met within the company and the employment relationship itself. This development reflects changes in the character not only of individual employment relationships but also of labour relations generally, guided towards forms that are in the broad sense participatory. 


18. Matters for further exploration

The observations made in this paper lead us to reflect on the new problems we face. They point to areas that will require further exploration, because clearly the subject of employment and its regulation presents more uncertainties than definite trends. 

The components of the new employment mosaic are only partially clarified, which means that all the new developments analysed here are problematic. 

The present objectives and functions of labour law are more fully developed than those historically concerned with the protection of workers, and they are not easy to fit into a pattern . Our discipline, with its different protagonists and ever more levels of regulation, is required to satisfy tangible and intangible needs more complex than those of the workers of the industrial era.

Certainly, workers still need protection, but their needs are becoming more complex because that have to respond to new circumstances, in terms of different kinds of employment ─ whether subordinate, freelance or mixed ─ and of the contexts in which they are performed. Present-day production systems are far removed from the Henry-Ford-style model, which has been disrupted by digital technologies and restricted in its decision-making by global competition.

If they are to be effective, the objectives and techniques of protection need to be changed, taking into account the variety of digital work and the functional requirements of global business. The reconciliation of different interests, which has always been the task of labour law, implies innovative choices, themselves having to be developed in conditions of uncertainty.

For this reason, our discipline is called to differentiate its interventions and develop a common core of employment standards that can be applied to all jobs. In this wider area of application, it needs to come to terms with human rights.

In addition, the increasing mobility and variability of both employment and the organization of production means that our discipline must equip itself with new legal and managerial tools to regulate the transitions between different jobs, which are an increasingly common aspect of people’s careers. 

In this respect, labour law plays the part of a labour market institution, able to make the market work more efficiently from an economic and social point of view. Our discipline needs to perform new tasks. One such task is to optimize job opportunities, and this applies to all jobs, from subordinate, freelance and third-sector jobs to service jobs and those of social importance, which the market penalizes because it fails to value them. Another task will be to improve the quality of human capital, providing support for continuous professional development as jobs and workers become more mobile. (2000, p. 521)

In international best practice, support for the transition between one job and another is not provided only for the unemployed, but is also available in anticipation of changes and corporate crises, involving enterprises themselves in policies to develop and upgrade their workers’ skills and competencies (OECD, 2018). 

Thus, the regulation of labour relations is integrated with the task of promoting employment on the labour market and ensuring employment continuity and opportunity.

In this vision, which in truth is barely outlined in the various practices, labour law can become an instrument contributing to enterprise and market efficiency, as well as economic development (Davies). 

With this goal in mind, incentives and supplementary welfare of the kind mentioned above are of special significance, especially in a context of participatory labour relations.  With the spread of such phenomena, our discipline, the task of which is to balance the opposing (or differing) interests and values of labour and business, needs to take account of the need to pursue the interests of both in the context of a common effort to achieve improvements in quality and in the fair distribution of rewards.

Market volatility and uncertainty have put welfare and social security policies back centre stage, and call for closer links with employment policy. It is the task of both to meet the security needs of all workers, subordinate and self-employed. The latter’s needs are different and more diffuse than the risks covered by traditional social insurance; they require forms of coverage adapted to market instability and able to provide active security in unstable economic circumstances. 

Industrial relations are affected more directly than individual labour law by the new economic circumstances and changes in the relative strengths of the parties. As we have seen, the shift in the centre of gravity of collective bargaining to enterprise level is obliging the parties, and primarily the trade unions, to face up to new labour and business problems without the defences of national, legal and contractual regulation, often in competition with the initiatives of innovative management.

The ambitious objectives adopted by the protagonists of our discipline are being pursued under differing conditions within the various national contexts, and often in production sectors that are more or less exposed to the shocks of competition. 

The search for new solutions is being conducted, as we have seen, not only with more or less urgency but also with differing approaches. Differences are emerging even between neighbouring European countries, despite their common regulatory mechanisms, which have not withstood the growing populism and often nationalistic approach.

The diversity of regulatory systems co-exists with opposing global moves towards standardization, which some people believe could converge in the deregulation of traditional labour law arrangements.

The increasingly transnational dimension of labour and business matters calls for research to gain a deeper understanding of the implications of growing interdependence among national systems.

The regulation of these matters has rested on a network of instruments that have been put in place over time, but which are still fragile because they lack support from national governments.  

While all sectors of national legal systems are facing difficulties because of their territorial anchorage, the crisis in labour regulation is aggravated by the structural asymmetry between the increasing mobility of enterprises and the limited mobility of labour. 

In the absence of effective transnational regulation of working conditions, the tendencies towards competition and divergence among national systems are bound to increase. These tendencies express themselves in, and are reinforced by, growing inequalities in economic and social circumstances between and within countries. 

There are no predetermined outcomes where labour regulation is concerned, as our analysis confirms.  Nation states, which in the last century played a decisive role in constructing legal and social systems capable of improving people’s working and living conditions, are now called to apply themselves to the establishment and spread of supranational rules and institutions that can promote the same objectives of welfare and social progress for all the world’s citizens.

Accepting the present disparities in the global employment situation by concentrating national powers on the defence of the status quo would only magnify the imbalances and injustices and would betray the mission of our discipline, which is to fairly regulate the working and living conditions of all working people.



Vuoi saperene di più?

Compila il seguente form. Ti risponderemo il prima possibile!

Privacy: