Il professor Treu discute il ruolo dello Stato nelle relazioni industriali. Egli sostiene che lo Stato ha svolto un ruolo importante nello sviluppo di moderne relazioni industriali e che continua ad essere importante nonostante la globalizzazione.
1. The contribution of the States and of public policies to the formation of modern Industrial Relations
The modern system of Industrial Relations systems have been shaped in the course of a century by the initiative and with the contribution of different agents, public and private. Their major traits and functioning have been subject to legal regulation since the beginning. A prominent role has been plaid by State legislations, once the organizations of workers and their collective activity have grown above the local level and acquired a national dimension. The contents of the various regulations of on industrial relations have been different, reflecting the specific national traditions and realities, and have changed considerably over time: usually from repression to indifference (laissez-faire) to legitimation and often promotion of collective activities.
In many developed countries State regulations and policies, influenced in various ways by the collective actions of the social parties, have been decisive in building the main structures of national industrial relations: i.e. in defining the position of workers and of employers associations, the forms and the role of collective bargaining, and the place and limits of industrial conflict. Indeed the development of modern industrial relations in the same countries has been favored not only by specific regulations of collective activities, but also by general labor and welfare policies supporting the conditions of workers.
During the last century industrial relations, although following different models and paths of development, have become a major component of the modern pluralist and democratic national systems.
The great transformations of the world scenario intervened in the recent decades have posed unprecedented challenges not only to the established patterns of labor and industrial relations but indeed to the existing social and economic systems.
The challenges are so fundamental that quite a few experts of our field, not to speak of managers and politicians, envisage the decline of labor regulations. A recent analysis based on quantitative analysis of Industrial Relations change has argued that the trajectories of most (advanced) countries indicate a clear trend toward a universal neoliberal transformation of industrial relations and in general of the capitalistic systems, which would contradict.
In this perspective, which is indeed quite controversial, the decline of traditional industrial relations based on collective agreements as a major source of labor regulations might be substituted by Human Resource management and other forms of individual relations. A similar possibility would have a direct impact also on the study of labor relations. A declining legal and collective regulations, challenged by market force and substituted by managerial decisions, would cause a parallel reduction or irrelevance of our discipline.
However it is a fact that the forms of work and of employment relations built in the past century are threatened by the structural factors which altering most aspects of the economy and of the social life, namely globalization and technological innovations. Both factors are not new, but their influence has been growing in the last years at an unprecedented pace.
Even so there is evidence, and I will mention some, that the impact of these factors is not predetermined, but is influenced by the existing institutions and by the political decisions adopted in different times and in the various countries.
Indeed the present economic and social transformations are affecting the system of Industrial Relations even more directly than the legal status of the contract of employment, in so far as industrial relations are exposed, often without any protection, to the pressures of the markets, and because the diversification of work affects the very basis of collective action of the workers, more than the initiatives of the employers.
These factors have altered the power relations among the social parties to the detriment of the labor unions and account for the growing difficulties of Industrial Relations which are visible even in the strongest systems of central and Northern Europe.
2. The changing scenario of industrial relations and the (different) reactions of national States
The role of the national States in the field of industrial relations remains important in spite of the debilitating influence of globalization.
I will support this statement by analyzing the major regulations and policies adopted by the European Union and by some member States.
These European policies may be a significant testing ground for evaluating the reactions of labor law and industrial relations to the transformations of the world of work. The analysis of these reactions may also offer some arguments to test the opinions mentioned above which envisage an inevitable decline of Industrial Relations.
The various European States have different historical traditions and maintain quite a few differences also in labor regulations; particularly so if we consider the eastern countries to which the European Union has been recently enlarged.
But being members of the European Union has intensified the relations among the various countries and the exchange of practices also in labor matters. Moreover the Union as such has contributed to spread common practices and rules in the field of employment and industrial relations, which have built a common social dimension, usually named “social model”.
Relative to most other areas of the world this 'model' is characterized by high standards in the major aspects of labor regulations: guarantees of collective and individual social rights: statutory legal and collective regulations of working conditions; social security and welfare institutions which protect workers from economic and personal risks and respond to the essential needs of life; extensive practices of collective bargaining and of workers participation.
In spite of these achievements the established system of social rights and policies has not fully protected the European workers and citizens from the damages of the recent economic crisis. And it does not exempt our countries from facing the challenges of the future. Indeed these challenges are quite similar to those common to the rest of the world, which threaten the stability of traditional labor regulations and policies.
A part from different approaches to labor policies a common trend shows an increasing protagonism of the national States in many sectors of employment law, social security and even in industrial relations which is traditionally an area resistant to legal regulations.
In fact quite a few legislators have approved reforms concerning the major institutions of industrial relations: particularly the status of trade unions and of employers associations, the structure and effects of collective bargaining.
The traits of the industrial relations of the various European states are quite different, and the recent legal interventions are bound to increase this diversity.
3. Different industrial relations trends: union density
While the average rate of unionization has decreased in Europe from the peaks of last century, the national trends are quite variable. The decline has not affected the unions of the Scandinavian countries and of Belgium, while it has been marked even in countries traditionally characterized by strong unionism like Austria, Germany, the Netherlands. In Italy unionization has decreased from the maximum of 38,8 % of 1986 to 31,8% in 2014 and then has stabilized, but with a decline in the industrial sectors and a concentration of union members in public services, and among retired workers.
The decline of average Union density and the even more pronounced reduction of industrial conflict, which has been confined to the public sectors, are not fully reflected in the coverage and structure of collective bargaining.
Here the variations among countries are not comparable to those of Union density, due to the impact of other factors, in particular of legislation and of public policies concerning industrial relations.
4. The coverage of collective agreements: different legislative measures
The coverage of national collective agreements has continued to be relatively high also in countries where the rate of unionization has been traditionally low such as France and Spain and has further declined in recent years. This is due mainly to State legislations which have supported the application of national or multi employer collective agreements beyond the area of unions influence by way of various mechanism of legal extension of these agreements to all the firms and employees of the various economic sectors.
This promotional legislation has not been changed and indeed has been reinforced in some countries like Germany. While in the past the extension could be decided on the condition that the agreement covered the majority of the interested firms and employees, recent legislation has lifted this condition in order to facilitate the extension. It has provided that the extension can be ordered at request of the bargaining parties following a discretionary evaluation of the public authorities.
Moreover minimum wages have been introduced in Germany, one of the few countries of Europe, together with Italy, where they did not exist as a way to sustain the salaries of occasional and precarious types of work, so called mini jobs, which are much lower than the average.
Even in the countries like Italy where a legal system of extension does not exist, other forms of indirect support of the effects of the agreements are in place. Courts decisions and administrative provisions require the respect of the standards fixed by national agreements as a condition to receive various fiscal benefits. The same wage standards are relevant to determine the basis for social security contributions. The role and effectiveness of collective agreements have been indirectly sustained also by the law which recognize the right to bargain only to representative unions, in order to oppose the fragmentation and hence the weakening of the bargaining parties.
These legal interventions have been important in supporting collective agreements; even though it is doubtful that they may be sufficient to redress the balance of power which is now unfavourable for the unions.
Another form of promotional legislation has been adopted by some countries, and endorsed by EU directives which grant consultation and participation rights to workers representatives on major enterprise decisions affecting working conditions. The experience of countries where this participation is widely adopted (Germany in the first place) has shown positive results not only in facilitating employment relations, but also in improving both the welfare of workers and the productivity of firms.
This approach however requires a major change of attitude in the culture and practice of the social parties, particularly of the unions most dedicated to conflict and alien to participation.
An institutional support to participative industrial relations comes also in those countries where unions and employers associations have developed, with legal endorsement, a net of bilateral committees and organizations which administer a considerable number of welfare and training instruments. These bilateral institutions have resisted to the economic crisis and often to the changes of government.
The legislation of some countries, in particular France, has imposed to employers a duty to bargain periodically with the representative unions on a wide range of matters - wages and working conditions - both at the national and company levels. This duty to bargain, which originally (in the 1930ies) was introduced in the federal legislation of the USA, is intended to put pressure on the employers to open the doors to workers representatives; and in fact it seems to have contributed to support and extend the practice of bargaining, particularly at decentralized levels.
But here too the recent reforms in this area are not uniform. Some European states (Greece, Portugal, Rumania) have intervened in a direction opposite to that mentioned above because have restricted the criteria for the extension of national collective agreements thereby contributing to reduce their effective coverage.
Similarly the legislators of Spain, Portugal and Greece have limited the effects of national collective agreements by reducing the period in which they are binding beyond the date of expiration (so called “ultra effectiveness”); and other States have legally predetermined the maximum duration of the same agreements. These measures increase the difficulty of the unions to renew periodically these agreements and weakens their capacity to be an effective source of protection for the employees of the sectors concerned.
5. The impact of decentralization on the structure of collective bargaining
The transformation of work and of the markets have exerted strong pressure to decentralize the structure of collective bargaining which in quite a few European countries was rather centralized.
The first ‘victim ‘of decentralization has been the practice of central Consultation and concertation with the peak organizations of the social parties which the governments of many European countries adopted in the last decades of the last century with the purpose of acquiring consensus about the major economic and social policies. The reduced strength of the labor movement, the changed political scenario in many European countries and the growing global pressures have convinced most governments that they could do away with the consensus of the labor unions without great political and social damages. Moreover the economic crisis has reduced the public resources available for the distribution of those economic benefits which were widely used in the past to acquire the consensus of the social parties.
The decentralization process, which influences many economic fields, has put pressure also on the national sectorial collective agreements, which in quite a few European countries were traditionally the cornerstone of the bargaining structure.
The traditional function of national collective agreements of subtracting wages from competition has been weakened by globalization, particularly in the sectors and for the companies most exposed to foreign competition. For the same reasons the companies have been pushed to adapt the rules of employment relations to their specific needs and to change the standard regulations of national agreements, particularly those which limit the flexible use of workers necessary to respond to the variations of the markets.
Indeed a threat to the authority of national collective agreements has recently come not only from the reduced force and cohesion of the labor movement, but also from the decline and fragmentation of employers associations (which is a new aspect of societal dispersion).This fragmentation has affected also systems like the German which were traditionally very cohese.
Italy is an extreme case because the number of national collective agreements have exploded in the last ten years reaching almost ‘900: many of them have extremely limited coverage, are signed by associations of scarce or no representativeness and often fix wages and working conditions below the standard of decent work.
As a reaction to this situation the French legislator has introduced specific indicators to identify not only the most representative unions, but also the representativeness of the employers associations. These associations in order to be recognized as representative must meet the following indicators: the respect of republican values, the financial independence and transparency, a minimum of two years of bargaining activity, the influential character of their activity, and finally the number of firms adhering to the association (number variable according to the level of bargaining) (Act. August 2015, n. 994).
Proposals to introduce similar criteria for the representativeness of employers associations are being discussed also in Italy. Meanwhile the Italian labor Ministry can identify the most representative collective agreements on the basis of act 389/1989 modified by act 549/1995 (art.2, co.25), which provides that the wages relevant to calculate social security contributions cannot be lower than those fixed in the collective agreements concluded by the most representative unions. All employers must respect these standard wages under penalty of sanctions applied by the labor inspectors.
6. Factors and trends of decentralized bargaining
The reduced importance of national and multi employers agreements has left
space, to decentralized bargaining, mainly to the company and plant level, which has acquired a decisive role in most countries even where the national and multi employer agreements were traditionally prevalent
The national legislators have encouraged this process of decentralization on various conditions and with a different impact on the role of national agreements. Some legislations (Spain) have completely altered the traditional hierarchy of the bargaining structure by attributing to company agreements the primary role in regulating most labor issues, including the possibility to fix conditions of work less favorable to employees than those set nationally.
A more nuanced solution has been adopted in France where the law has attributed to decentralized agreements priority in the regulation of some issues not reserved to national agreements. But as indicated above, it has provided the duty of the employers to bargain periodically over most labor matters.
Similar measures have been decided, although less clearly, by Italian law, which has recognized to decentralized agreements, contrary to tradition, the same legal status and effectiveness as the national agreements. Moreover collective bargaining has been promoted in specific areas, because some fiscal incentives have been reserved to productivity bonuses and to welfare benefits bargained with the unions, and not to those unilaterally decided by management. These incentives have contributed to extend the practice of collective agreement to some sectors of small firms and to stimulate the adoption of participatory practices.
The impact of decentralization on industrial relations systems tends to be different not only as a consequence of these legislative interventions, but also depending on the
resilience of the systems themselves, i.e. on the reactions of the social parties.
In countries like Germany and Italy the central labor unions have been able to control the process of decentralization, at least in the strong economic sectors and in medium large firms; and have used the possibility to derogate from the national standards mainly in cases of serious economic crisis in order to prevent mass dismissals and plant closures.
The importance of maintaining some central control on decentralization is acknowledged by many scholars. They argue that an organized decentralization may allow to keep a good balance between the need to guarantee by national agreements some basic standards common to all the workers of a sector and the necessity of allowing specific HR regulations suitable for individual companies.
In fact the capacity of central agreements to coordinate the basic standards of employment, in particular of wages, is still to be appreciated, because according to the OECD a coordinated bargaining structure reduces wage unbalances and allows for better employment results, particularly for the most vulnerable groups of workers.
The decentralization process of industrial relations has been promoted by employers associations; but they have not pushed to abolish national and multi employer bargaining, in this respect converging with the position of the unions. Workers organizations are committed to safeguard the social function of national agreements as guarantee of equality in the basic conditions of work for the employees of the same economic sectors. The employers associations have accepted to maintain this level of bargaining even though reduced in content and made more flexible, in order to respond to the different needs of the firms, because national agreements have proved to be useful to regulate employment contracts of the multitude of small firms, often marginal, which represent the majority in many sectors of the economy. Centralized bargaining has been useful also to exempt these firms from the direct impact of unions and social pressure. At the same time national agreements leave room to the more productive enterprises to regulate differently their employees according to their specific needs.
However the trends prevailing in most countries indicate a marked alteration of the structure of continental collective bargaining . The national agreements are becoming similar to framework contracts setting basic standards and guidelines more than regulating the actual conditions of work. Wages tend to be linked, above the minima, to the performance of workers and to indicators of business productivity and results.
Decentralized agreements tend to become firm-specific, i.e. dedicated to solve problems of work organization and to administer the daily life of the workplace, mostly through specialized procedures and bilateral committees. In many advanced companies participatory bargaining is competing with innovative HR management for the allegiance of the new and old types of employees.
The decentralization process of the collective bargaining structure has general implications indicating the (renewed or acquired) centrality of enterprises in the national and global economy, especially since this decentralization is not only “spatial” and technical, but is also becoming normative, giving the enterprise a central role in the “system of market regulation”.
8. State policies and the promotion of participatory practices.
These implications of decentralization, in general and for the quality of industrial relations, cannot be evaluated in isolation, but depend on the economic and social context in-which the parties operate. In particular State regulations may prevent solutions unfavorable to workers, often the weaker part of the deal or instead they can favor bargaining practices capable of better combining the needs of the two parties and of promoting agreements useful both to the company efficiency and to the welfare of workers.
State policies of the type indicated above are decisive in this respect and have evolved quite differently in the various countries. The central importance-acquired by company bargaining would require a revision or the reinforcement of a promotional legislation capable of rebalancing the power relations between the parties. In the tradition of European industrial relations state legislations have supported the collective action of workers by recognizing the basic rights of organization, of bargaining and (even) of participation within the enterprises.
The legislation of those Central European countries, beginning with Germany, which have promoted participatory rights of workers representatives, including rights to codetermination has favored such a rebalancing. And there is evidence that the ensuing practices of collaborative labor management relations have produced positive results by contributing to improve both firm productivity and employment conditions of the employees.
The new competitive and technological conditions in which firms are called to operate appear to increase the importance of workers participation and involvement Particularly in the most advanced technological environments the involvement of employees as individuals and in team works has proved to be an effective Instrument for promoting innovation and competitiveness. But recent research confirms that the implications of this type of involvement are ambivalent. Often it develops mainly at management initiative or outside unions channels, particularly in the countries where the unions have no legal power to intervene in work organization.
Experiments of direct workers participation in this area are spreading also in a country like Italy where industrial relations have been traditionally based on adversarial collective bargaining. And they have been promoted by Italian legislation (act 232/2016) which has granted special fiscal incentives to the employers who negotiate productivity bonuses and also establish bilateral forms of employees participation.
The labor unions are called to respond to this new challenge on penalty of leaving to management an important ground of action which may enrich the value of participation, particularly for employees who are not reached by traditional collective activities.
It is up to the unions to place these forms of “micro participation” in the wider context of labour management relations, so that the scope and influence of collective participation may be extended to all business activities and strategies, as it has been in the most valuable national traditions.
The need to reconsider the meaning of participation is further emphasized by the emergence of new forms of enterprise organization, network firms, multinational and multifunctional employers. The challenge for the unions and for workers representatives is to restore some unity of purpose among the fragments of participation dispersed in the multiple functions of the firm and to finalize them to common collective objectives. Here too a useful contribution could come by a new kind of promotional legislation addressing the role and powers of workers representatives at shop floor level which remains a decisive area of influence also in the new context of fluid multifunctional firms. A second important contribution would be to strengthen the links between shop floor representatives and other levels of unions organization.
9. Unions revitalization policies
For the reason indicated above State support to collective bargaining and to workers participation particularly at the decentralized company level is important even more than in the past to redress the balance of powers among the parties.
But the future of the industrial relations depends in the first place on the capacity of the labor movement to find new reasons and objectives for a common action.
The growth and influence of the European unions have been built, differently from the trend prevailing in the USA, not only on collective bargaining, but on a vast spectrum of social and political actions, including the participation within the enterprises and in public institutions in charge of labor policies, training and welfare policies.
The value of this multiplicity of arenas in face of the present global transformations, has been confirmed by most European unions, even though their relations with the traditional labor parties has been loosened, and the declining fortunes of labor friendly governments have often reduced their financial and institutional support to unions activities.
The decline of membership and the increasingly difficult relationship with the State have persuaded many European unions to experiment innovative forms of recruiting activities similar to those practiced by American unions, in particular towards the new types of employees, skilled and unskilled, which populate the present labor markets.
American scholars similarly stress the importance of new forms of worker advocacy on issues like recruitment, wages and the use of artificial intelligence and machine learning tools to advise workers of their rights.
These practices of union-revitalization have met with uneven degree of success, at least in Europe, in overcoming the obstacles which contrast collective action and organization.
Forms of collaboration and alliance with other types of social movements have been searched by some unions; but in most cases have remained at an initial stage, due to the difficulty to find common objectives with the traditional goals and often to the resistance of the unions leadership.
In fact greater attention has been given by the unions of the major European countries to service activities of different kinds (social assistance, training services). These services have proved useful not only to increase the allegiance of members and the attractiveness of membership, but also to compensate for the reduced amount of member dues and of public resources available to labor unions.
10. Instruments of social regulation of international trade
A major challenge to industrial relations, and indeed to the whole system of labor law and social security comes from the diffusion of enterprises on a global scale. The challenge goes to the roots of our discipline because labor laws and industrial relations have been nationally based and supported by national state policies.
The unions have tried to expand their organization and some activities, including strike action, at the supranational level. But the resources devoted to these activities are still limited and the international workers representatives have not received from their national constituencies sufficient power to face the power of multinational enterprises.
More political and intellectual investments are necessary to change the contents and techniques of national regulations and policies in order to enable them to operate effectively across national borders.
The various national actors, public institutions, employers associations and labor unions, together with the relevant international organizations, have been trying to respond to this challenge and have adopted different techniques to shape supranational principles and regulations.
The complexity of the issues involved and the variety of the actors of international trade have given rise to a diversification of forms of regulation: directives and recomendations of international organizations (ILO, OECD in the first place); social clauses inserted in international treaties; general systems of preference (GSP); codes of practices of multinational enterprises; transnational collective agreements.
The difference of these sources and of the matters affected has brought about an extreme variety of contents and techniques of regulation, plus different systems of implementation.
But the effectiveness of these rules beyond national borders is limited by the fact that lacking supranational authorities the instruments defining and implementing the rules and of common legal principles, still depend on the intervention of national States. This is the case of social clauses in international trade agreements. They have the consensual form of a contract but an interstate substance; and this substance is even more prominent in the implementation phase whose effectiveness depends on the decisions of the public agencies of the States signatory to the agreements.
Similarly the international collective agreements which have recently increased in numbers and improved their contents don’t have any common supranational legal status and are effective only within the national systems. The States could well recognize legal force to these agreements in accordance with the regulations applicable to national collective agreements. Some proposals to this extent have been advanced but so far not adopted.
However it is worth noticing a recent French legislation (of 2017) which has imposed to the dominant enterprises of a group the duty to supervise the activities of their peripheral units and has held them responsible for the damages caused by the violation of human rights and of environmental standards committed by these units also outside the national territories.
However so far national States have not invested enough in supporting the implementation of the supranational rules, particularly in the field of labor and industrial relations. In spite of the fact that the international arena is a decisive ground where the States are challenged to continue beyond their national borders the historical task of main regulators of employment and industrial relations.
The multinational enterprises have acquired a major importance in international affairs and their influence is far greater than that exerted by the weak international projections of social parties, labor unions in particular.
Moreover the regulation of social and employment relations is not the primary objective of these companies and is largely subtracted from any public influence.
Improving the quality and the effectiveness of transnational social regulations is not a merely technical task. It would require a change in the strategy of the various actors. The enterprises should accept more stringent social obligations than those resulting from the codes of practice. The States could require the enterprises to abide by the social standards included in the trade agreements and/or to give binding force to the principles of corporate social responsibility.
But most important, they should give priority in their political agenda to supporting the influence of social rules in international relations.
The examples drawn from the European countries confirm and indeed stress the diversity of the solutions adopted, by national States to meet the present challenges to the world of work. The diversity, even the polarization, between the various labor policies and regulations have significant influence on the national social and economic systems and may be considered as contributing to the varieties of capitalism.
It is uncertain whether the social policies so far implemented, even the most successful, will be sufficient to counteract the negative factors which have contributed to the decline of unions powers, of collective bargaining and to the weakening of labor rights.
The evaluations by experts and politicians of the possible impact of these measures are divergent and not yet conclusive.
As I mentioned above they range from those which envisage a neoliberal convergence of most social and legal systems, which implies a reduced capacity to protect the rights of workers, to opinions which consider the present changes as a necessary adaptation of the traditional regulatory and welfare measures to the new global and technological conditions. According to this latter opinion the legal and social innovations represent not a simple retrenchment, but a repositioning of our social and legal systems necessary to face the present economic transformations and to defend, if not all the acquired rights of the core workers at least the essential standards of decent work for the persons who perform the various activities, often atypical, present in the mobile labor markets of today.
The implications of the measures implemented by the European States are also uncertain. Adapting different measures in the various countries, and even within the same country in the various economic sectors and areas, may be necessary to match the policy measures to the diversity of the factual conditions. To some extend it may correspond to the increased complexity of our social and economic systems.
But most critics emphasize the risk that this trend might lead to a stable dualism of legal and industrial relations regimes and contradict the mission of our discipline to promote social justice and progress for all workers and citizen.
In any case the examples presented here confirm the importance of the initiative of the national States and of the national social actors in determining the major trends of labor and industrial relations. Their strategies can make the difference even in the present global scenario.
Indeed some States are reasserting their authority in labor regulations and resisting to the global pressures in response to the denounce by their constituencies of the danger of globalization.
The success of these initiatives will depend on the conditions of the various States, but also on their capacity to innovate the policy mix in the directions exemplified above: e.g. a more selective use of legislation concentrated on basic standard to be applied universally, a better balance between flexibility in the firms and security in the labor market, supported with active labor policies and income guarantees; increased investments in basic and digital education and in continuous training; promotion of workers participation in the enterprise and of unions involvement in the administration of social security and placement services.
The institutions of the European Union have exerted significant influence also in the area of labor regulations and welfare, using many instruments, often indirect, but more stringent than those available to other supranational and international institutions.
The policies of the Union have been changing in the years. Recently they have given priority to safeguarding financial stability with austerity measures even at the expenses of policies aimed at supporting economic growth.
The government of the European Union following this priority has influenced in various degrees the decisions of members states in economic and social matters. In the States most endangered by financial and economic crisis its decisions have severely limited the capacity to freely determine the most important public policies and have forced them to implement drastic forms of internal devaluation.
The reactions of the public opinion have provoked social and political repercussions in many countries, including the rise of anti- European movements. These reactions may have contributed to the recent proposals of the European Commission envisaging a reorientation of its priority towards growth enhancing policies.
It remains to be seen if and to what extent this new approach will materialize and will produce significant changes in labor policies and regulations. Even experts not prejudiced against the Union are skeptical and forecast that further inertia of the European institutions may contribute to the revival of nationalism also in labor regulations.
I am convinced that labor regulations are still an important elements of the social order. If well framed they can positively contribute to economic competitiveness and to sustainable development. But as already mentioned good regulations and social policies are only one contributing factor to this end. The whole range of public policies must be finalized to the objective of creating a more inclusive and sustainable growth. The economic and financial strategies adopted by the States and by the European Union will have a decisive influence also on our field.
Compila il seguente form. Ti risponderemo il prima possibile!