Il Green Deal europeo e le transizioni verde e digitale cambiano lavoro, imprese e politiche del lavoro, ponendo nuove sfide a diritto e relazioni industriali.
The decision to devote an international seminar in Venice to the challenges of climate change to labour law and labor policies is very timely, given the dramatic urgency to adopt climate policies and actions needed for the very survival of the planet. The seminar is particularly important because it draws the attention, so far insufficient, of our discipline to the implications of climate change for the world of work and indeed for our future destinies.
This lack of attention is not limited to our area of studies but is common to other social sciences and has been shared until recently also by the main representative social actors, whose primary preoccupation has been to bargain (only) about the results of growth and in particular about its distribution.
This has been true also for the trade unions, whose action has rarely raised issues concerning the scope and quality of production. When this has been done, it was for verifying the impact of production. and of the economy on the conditions of work and not on the safeguard of the environment.
Even when the international agenda and the new course of the European Commission have highlighted the objective of sustainability as a central guideline for our future public and private policies, the attention of the social parties and of most experts has been on the social aspects of sustainability,and (sometime) on how to find a possible compromise between economic and social sustainability.
The reasons of the environment have been by and large disregarded or marginalised until recently.
The fact of the matter is that Including the respect of the environment in the essence of sustainability implies drastic changes in the structures of our productive and economic systems which have been prevailing during the industrial era for a century.
The impact of the green transition on our industrial activities is already creating strong tensions among the social parties and difficulties of the public powers which are asked to sustain massive processes of enterprises restructuring and the relocation of thousands of workers.
Some observers and trade unions are inclined to argue that the reasons of the environment are incompatible with those of employment. In any case the targets fixed by the European authorities with the Green deal and the objective fit for 55 are considered by many too ambitious and possibly disruptive of the European industrial system, particularly in countries like Germany and Italy.
A most important challenge for the policy makers of our countries is to provide positive evidence that the objectives and practices of the green transition can be reconciled with the safeguard of production and of employment .
Even more important is to demonstrate that the new model of production envisaged by the Next generation Eu (NGEU), based on the twin transitions green and digital, may not only promote a more sustained growth, but also be favourable to a better quality both of the environment and of employment. The institutions responsible for social policies and the collective parties should be the first drivers in showing that quality of work and quality of development are reciprocally functional.
2) Changing the existing ecomonomic structures for sustainable development
The ambitious targets set by the European programs Indeed the NGEU is based on this assumption, namely that the three dimensions of sustainability, economic, social and environmental, can go together and can reinforce each other.
The investments and the reforms provided by the National recovery and resilience plans following the NGEU are in fact finalised to support member states in pursuing these ambitious and interconnected objectives.
The fist implementation of these plans however has proved quite difficult not only due to the complexity and the tight schedule fixed for the execution of the various projects, but also because the pursuance of the digital and the green transition requires a drastic change of most economic and industrial practices prevailing in the industrial era.
This process of change will prove particularly difficult in the short period, because its introduction will produce shocks in many existing productions, while alternative solutions are not immediately available. That is why a long term perspective will have to be taken by both public authorities and social parties in implementing the various aspects of the transitions in order to reduce the negative impact of this time gap.
Time will be necessary to implement the combination of innovative policies necessary to adapt the industrial structures to the new scenario and to promote the welfare measures needed to compensate for the damages caused during the transition to the workers.
The implications of these changes are wide ranging and not yet fully understood by the public and private actors which must implement them.
The enterprises are requested to change their governance and strategies in order to made them consistent with the objectives of sustainable development and to enable them to contribute to their attainment, in particular to the prevention and the mitigation of the negative environmental impact of the traditional activities.
Specific european guidelines and proposed directives require that companies report their plans to ensure that these objective are being pursued. Moreover the companies active on the international markets are asked to control that not only their operations, but also those of the subsidiaries and units of their supply chains minimise the adverse impact on the environment and on human rights.
These requirements go beyond the traditional contents attributed to the corporate social responsibility , and are being monitored by national and European authorities in order to prevent greenwashing practices.
Moreover the European regulations concerning the implementation of the National recovery plans (2020/852 art 17) have provided even more rigorous conditions on the activities financed with the NGEU funds.
3) The principle not significant harm and positive contributions to a just transition
All these activities must respect ,as a major condition for receiving the funds, the principle “do not significant harm”(DNSH)i.e. do not affect negatively the status of the environment and guarantee a basic compliance to the European green strategy
The respect of this principle is required for all projects under the national recovery Plans. The conformity to it must be evaluated in advance by the public institutions responsible of the projects, but it will impose obligations to all enterprises implementing the activities.
Even though the impact of this requirement is yet to be fully evaluated, its implementation appears to be very complicate and might create quite a few difficulties to company practices.
A critical issue will be how to balance the respect of the DNSH principle with the normal activities and the freedom of action of private business
A recent document of the ILO, based on extensive research, has stated that the conduct of enterprises is crucial to the natural environment and for a just transition , and has indicated how their conduct can positively contribute to this end.
Most areas of the enterprise strategy and organisation will have to be changed : from the use of renewable energy and sustainable raw materials,to the adoption of technologies capable to produce more with the same level of input ,to greening the places of work and promoting less consumption of resources and sustainable transportation.
The research indicates that a large majority of enterprises has already taken some initiative in this direction ,but more must be done ,particularly by SME, in order to adopt a systematic long term approach to the green strategy particularly by SME .
This new approach is in fact present in many NGEU projects and in the available resources which are aimed at supporting the adoption of green practices in production and services .
These practices ,together with the adoption of digital technologies, will imply radical changes in many aspects of the employment relations ,individual and collective: from the organisation of work, to its evaluation and reward systems, to the prevention and safeguard of heath and safety .
This open a new area of research for both practitioners and experts of industrial relations ,including labor law scholars .
We are challenged to understand which kind of innovations the new green and digital environment of production will introduce in the design and contents of employment: a new context (terra incognita) where our acquired categories will not be sufficient and might possibly be misleading.
4) The impact of the green deal on the quantity and quality of work
So far the prevailing attention of labor lawyers has been devoted to the impact of the digital platform on the legal qualification of employment.
To this question is addressed the proposed European directive on platform work which establish a presumption of subordination for those employment relations which present some objective characters, mostly in line with those adopted to the same end by many courts of our states.
But the impact is far more widespread, because both the digital and green transitions will greatly influence the future quantity and quality of work.
On the first aspect the opinions (mostly of the economics) and the forecast are uncertain, ranging from an extreme pessimism to a moderate optimism.
Some national recovery plans, including the Italian, are rather optimistic and estimate that their full implementation will contribute to a considerable increase in the rate of employment (in Italy 3,6%).
The ILO projections present a similar outlook and estimate that by 2030 the green transition will greatly affect employment with approximately 25 million new jobs created and over 7 million present jobs disappearing
All estimates indicate that the transition will greatly influence the quality of employment. Even though the characters relevant for qualification of green jobs are variously appreciated by the national labor statistics and experts, most of them will require skills quite different from those prevailing in the traditional economy.
According to Italian estimates shared between CNEL and the information system of the chambers of commerce a great majority of future jobs (60%) will require green skills of an average level and 37% of high level.
The ILO estimates underlines the great need of new skill in order to tap into the jobs opportunities offered by the green transition and the urgency to face with appropriate policies the serious skill shortage.
The presence of green jobs will be distributed ,although unevenly ,in many sectors including traditional industries and constructions; urban renewal and energy efficiency of public and private buildings will be a major source of them. But similar new skills will be needed also in many service sectors, beginning with services of personal care.
Meeting these new needs will require not only major investments in education and in continuous training but also a renewal of their contents aimed at linking them to the needs emerging from the implementation of the two transitions.
According to a recent Reccomandation of the European Council (14.1. 2022 COM 2022 final) “learning for environmetal sustainability” integrating the principles of environmental sustainability in all the programs and process of education and training is essential to develop the skills and abilities necessary to support the green transition.
This recommendation for the need of a coherent approach to the competences skills and attitudes of people for promoting sustainability.
5) Continuos training and active labor policy to manage the transitions
Moreover these transitions will change the geography of the economy with the rapid growth of new sectors and decline of others ,which will require a relocation of material and human resources of great dimensions and consequently a unprecedented challenge to our systems of training and active labour policies.
The Italian National recovery plan devotes significant resources to support both the investment in training and the economic assistance to the displaced employees. But the dimension and novelty of the challenge will require not only more economic resources but new institutions dedicated to finalise the new educational and labor policies to successfully manage the transitions. This is particularly the case of Italy where the existing instruments of active labor policies have proved inadequate also to perform their ordinary functions�The National plans assign to the State and the local governments the major responsibility for the management of the various projects. At the same time the European regulation (2021/241, art 18), calls for a true and continuous involvement of the social parties and of the organised society in their implementation.
The activities needed for this implementation are so numerous and decentralised in the various sectors and territories that the success of the plan will depend on the mobilisation and common efforts of all the actors, private and private, of the country.
In particular this is true for the innovation and management of active labor policies and continuous training which are the main instruments necessary to support the transitions of both workers and enterprises.
The impact of the two transitions on the labor market has destabilised the traditional relationship about the jobs and skills required by the enterprises and the competences traditionally offers by the school system.
This disconnection has dramatised the job skill mismatch and challenged the firms to reassess their recruiting and training programs, with or without agreement with the unions, with special attention to fill the gaps in digital and green skills.
In order to prevent this mismatch structural measure are needed. One major project supported by the Italian national recovery plan aims at reinforcing the system of school guidance for better informing and directing young students in the choices of their studies.
The Italian unions confederations and the central organisations of employers seem to have perceived the importance of these issues. A few national and decentralised agreements have set up bilateral bodies aimed at organising the reskilling of employees and at supporting their reallocation.
However the diffusion of these initiatives is still limited, Whereas the dimension of the challenge would require a general involvement of the social parties together with the public authorities in the elaboration and management of training and active labor policies.
6) Greening the organisations
A most important area of common concern of both management and employees representative is how to adapt to the green and digital environment the organisation of business and of work prevailing in the industrial tradition.
As indicated in the ILO document changes will have to be introduce in most aspects of enterprise life, from the greening of the work places to the dematerialisation of many processes, to the alteration of the very sense of time and place consequent to the use of telework.�A major contribution to these targets may come from the diffused use of the various forms of remote working allowed by digital technologies.
Intelligent work practices experimented in many firms, usually following Union management agreements, have showed that this type of work particularly when implemented in a hybrid combination of activities partly remore and partly in presence ,may favour not only a better work life balance but also a more productive use of time and a reduction of energy consumption.
These positive results are most likely to materialise in firms which have a wider combination of innovative practices, concerning the organisation of work, investments in continuous training and labor mobility, and effective involvement of workers in the management of these issues.
Extensive research shows a possible positive impact of working time organisation on the sustainability both social and environmental of productive processes but warns that the outocome of Of these work pattern is not to be taken for granted and depends on the general management of employement relations on the enterprise.
Improvements of these processes have been made possible by quite a few collective agreements signed, particularly at the enterprise level ,which have adopted various regimes of flexible working time ,possibly combined with the reduction of working hours. These win win combinations can be maximised if the new regimes of work are extended to the majority of firms and connected with a parallel renovation of the systems of transportation and of city planning.
The regulation of this new set of issues is already present not only in some enterprise wide collective agreements, but also in some territorial accords between the social parties with the participation of local governments which tackle the wider implications of remote working on the external environment.
The use of remote working presents uncertain traits and impact both on the conditions of employment and on the management of the firms. For this reasons it is advisable to leave the regulation of its various aspects to collective agreements or, as proposed by the Italian act 81/2017, to a combination of collective and individual contracts.
At least in this still experimental phase, the legislative intervention could more appropriately be limited to regulate some basic rights like that of disconnection and the aspects of prevention and safeguard of heath and safety of workers operating in the variable spaces and context of remote digital activities.
7) Health and safety in the work places and in the environment: one health
The legislation on these latter issues has to face an aspect which has been barely considered so far, namely the connections between the quality and the risks of the work place and the external environment.
The increased permeability allowed by technologies between the borders of the firm and the external space, has made more clear than ever the importance of these connections ,in both directions.�It has showed that the negative consequences of dangerous and unhealthy conditions of work on the environment are more widespread than in the extreme cases of ecological disasters reported in many countries of the world (from Chernobyl to Fukushima) and consequently must be considered in the basic labor law regulation of the matter.
In the other direction the experience of the covid pandemic has given renewed evidence that the pollution of the environment not only threatens the health of the population, particularly of the weakest members , but may also endanger the workers by worsening their personal conditions and reducing their resistance to the conditions and burdens of work .
The importance of these bidirectional connections is signaled in the international documents in particular of the ILO report quoted by Hendricks, which remind us that the workplace wellbeing relates to all aspects of working life, from the quality and safety of the physical place to the entire working environment.
Even so the implications for policy action have yet to be fully explored. A prerequisite in guiding this research should be to abandon the traditional approach still prevailing in our culture and legal systems which tends to maintain the separation between workplace and external regulations: a first challenge to this approach would be to leave the strict definition of the legal notion of professional risk and extend it to consider more general risks to which all persons which work are exposed
8) Impact on the evaluation and reward of work
The changes promoted by the various aspects of “greening the enterprise “mentioned so far should have direct implications on the systems of evaluation and reward of the employees.
Innovations in both areas are present in some innovative management practices and collective agreements, but the good examples are far from prevailing in actual practice.
The systems of job classification adopted by firms and collective agreements have been rather resistant to innovation ; recent agreements like that of the Italian metalworking industry, have been concentrated in reshaping the roles of the different categories of employees in the intent to respond to the need of flexibility and of internal mobility, without specific concern for environmental implications.
.�But if the changes in the organisation of work mentioned above must be finalised to environmental improvements and the employees are requested to contribute to this end , this should have some impact on the classification and evaluation of the different jobs .
These changes and improvements may be reflected not only in the structure of basic wages but also and possibly more directly in the various systems of incentives and payments by result .
In the last years the number and quantitative importance of these payments by result ,often connected with welfare benefits, have greatly increased ,also due to the fiscal incentives that many legislators including the Italian have introduced to support them .
The Italian legislation has distributed the incentives to these pay systems and to welfare benefits in a rather indifferentiated way, which has dispersed resources and reduced their impact .
In order to be consistent with the paradigm of sustainability the reward systems should be more selective and its emphasis should also move away from the traditional criteria of material productivity so as to give more weight to the indicators proposed by the sustainability agenda 2030 and to the individual and collective contributions that employees give to them
9) Concluding remarks
A reflexive analysis on the transformations undergoing in present times should draw our attention on some key points useful for future action.
Fist it demands to be fully aware of the challenge posed by the two transitions to our economic and social institutions and of the need to change not only specific policies and regulations but the basic orientation of our development in line with the complex parameters of sustainability (SDG of the 2030 Agenda).
This awareness should sustain a comprehensive approach to future policy making finalised to allow the transitions to be just and to mobilise to this end all public and private actors of our countries.
The public institutions which have a major responsibility in guiding the transitions together with the social parties and organised society which are requested to participate to this renovation of public policies, must face some basic issues which have been for long eluded: namely what and how to produce, what and how to consume, in order to be consistent with the three dimensions of a sustainable development.
The two transitions have great technical and economic implications, but are also a transformative force which is influencing our whole life, and in perspective even our culture and mindset.
For this reason the success and the very justice of the transitions will require not only comprensive policies and regulations, implemented by coordinated efforts of all the public and social actors, but also consistent changes in the priorities, approach and strategies of the same actors.
In short, the new paradigms of development and their implications for the justice of the transitions must be internalised by the actors to become effective.
Compila il seguente form. Ti risponderemo il prima possibile!